Can soil compete with hydro yields? Please read

[Dr.Nick Riviera]

I grow in peat moss and only water every 3rd day,just sayin.

 

[Rrog]

I've seen soooo many grows over the decades where a hydro grower butchers a soil grow just to make a point.

 

[Rrog]

I didn't say microbes = bugs, I just said that you need to build a little eco system if you are going natural soil route. I like permaculture as a concept but you need a lot of plant diversity to take a full advantage of it

No

 

[The_Enthusiast]

As of hydro, who ever is using premixed or better yet premixed liquid fertilizers is wrong, so as I saw most of people are using them I am not surprised that they are doing better in soil than in "that hydro"

 

[Dr.Nick Riviera]

once you start growing with organic soil and LED lights, you have to move to san francisco and start smelling your own farts.

 

[The_Enthusiast]

once you start growing with organic soil and LED lights, you have to move to san francisco and start smelling your own farts.

Little off-topic, the LAW in my country states:
If you add artificial light to plants - its no longer considered organic so you cant claim organic producer status

 

[Chunky Stool]

Sure but you get all the benefits I listed and you get hydro results without all the hydro work

My lobelia plant did great last year. Final repotting was 1 gallon w/FFOF, which worked with plain water for about a month, then I started seeing deficiencies. So I gradually started feeding Dyna-Gro Foliage Pro, and by the end of the year, it was a beast!
So it was transitioned slowly from 100% organic to hydro nutes -- and did great.
I bet the same technique would work for cannabis.

 

[meangreengrowinmachine]

Grow a tomato in soil...then grow a tomato in hydro..eat them and then come back and describe the difference in flavour.

yeah i have... homegrown tomatoes in soil are by far far better then hydro imo... as i said though each to their own man have at it .. (-: isnt that what this is all about anyway?

 

[Rrog]

I bet a cannabis plant or corn plant would look similar if grown in soil vs. hydro

 

[The_Enthusiast]

To be honest Rrog, I see the appeal of "little eco system in every pot for full plant nutrition + benefits of nematodes and bacteria and so on".
But, maybe I am arrogant, I believe the science has advanced so much its possible to suppress soil performance with hydro doing it the right way. Biggest concern about soil is it's impossible to feed nutrients, water and oxygen to roots in the same time. Something is always (in a moment) neglected.

I'm planing to build a greenhouse of vegetables for me personally and few friends. I'll be running everything in hydroponics but I'll be using only heirloom vegetable not commercial/greenhouse strains.

 

[Rrog]

I think the value of "Science and scientists" went out the door in the 50's. Science isn't a religion, and scientists are not divine. Unfortunately the "science" is in favor of corporations and all the goodness they bring.

And you can EASILY test two tomatoes and determine whose is more nutrient dense.

And you will not be seeing the benefits of microbes. This is the big folly.

 

[The_Enthusiast]

I never tried good hydro vegetable in my life, everything i tried sucked. But I'm blaming bad genetics and bad hydro practices/knowlage.

I'm waiting for a day when i try to grow something like this:

In "my" hydro system and formula.

When that day comes I'll contact you. As now - I never had good hydro vegetable...

 

[Rrog]

All this fuss when soil works great. I consider hydro a hobby- passing fad with no sustainability

 

[Phatlewtz]

Imo im a complete newb iv only ever smoked shitty weed i know its hydro tho n theres no smell or flavour but im pretty sure who ever grew it doesn't no shit nobody seems 2 in my neck of the woods

Sounds like my kind of market...where you at?

 

[The_Enthusiast]

All this fuss when soil works great. I consider hydro a hobby- passing fad with no sustainability

Its in human nature to try to make something better, sometimes it works sometimes it's a dead end - time will tell.

 

[Rrog]

Completely human nature for men. Not so much for women, and there's something to be said for that.

The US food supply has not helped Americans. Time has already told. We are sick. Among the sickest. Fortunately we also pay 5X what our neighbors do for that great health care.

 

[giglewigle]

Sounds like my kind of market...where you at?

australia the weed smells like hay why would that be ur thing lol

 

[Rrog]

The Enthusiast gets the avatar of the day prize. Just sayin'. It's groovy

 

[The_Enthusiast]

I agree that corporations destroy (systemically) peoples health. But to be honest hydroponics was used even in ancient world - so the concept of soilless culture is not something that is bad.

Now to general population - people, in my experience, are dumb and lazy (especially now with cellphones and everything). To eat good and exercise is a choice not something you are born into.

In my country average yearly salary is around 8.700€ and everything is more (20-30%) expensive than in USA (cars are sometimes 2-3x more expensive - gas as well 2-3x) and still if you want, you can eat well but not from supermarkets or mcdonalds....

 

[Phatlewtz]

australia the weed smells like hay why would that be ur thing lol

Seems like an easy market to own if you got that fire!

and if I was there I could run around chanting "Aussie Aussie Oi Oi Oi!"