Smart Pots

ODOK

Member
How smart are these pots, really? Watering is a complete nightmare, makes a mess and requires a lot more time. When watering a regular old pot it seems to take the water in evenly, with these smart pots it's soaked in some places and dry AF in others.

Think I'm going to ditch these after harvest. Anyone else have experience watering these things?
 

dynospec

Well-Known Member
put a tray underneath them, and simply be patient. ensuring your soil mix has good drainage will help loads. the same thing happens to regular pots when they arent fully saturated its just harder to see. Im doing my first hands on grow with them right now and have been happy so far.
 

meangreengrowinmachine

Well-Known Member
Are you talking fabric pots (love em) or those pieces of shit plastic jobs with all the holes in them (worst money I spent on growing) i have heard that the latter are much better suited to a drip system or something that will keep them moist all the time but never tried it with mine... I used them for about a month then transplanted as soon as I could out of them... and now they sit in a box somewhere.... where they will most likely stay lol
 

dynospec

Well-Known Member
Im pretty sure hes talking about the fabric ones, I like them so far myself aswell. Got a few 10 gallon ones to throw outside in the summer, should be exciting haha.
 

Cobnobuler

Well-Known Member
I thought I liked them too until Doc and a few of us kicked that subject around. As it turns out, often with the fabric pots you'll see postmortem that the roots stopped as much as 5 inches in or so all the way around the circumference of the pot. As such it becomes wasted precious real estate all around that area. Theres some videos out there that show this occurring,and I proved it to myself when the runs I used them in finished up.
Based on all that, I went back to the plastic pots.
 

Enots

Well-Known Member
I thought I liked them too until Doc and a few of us kicked that subject around. As it turns out, often with the fabric pots you'll see postmortem that the roots stopped as much as 5 inches in or so all the way around the circumference of the pot. As such it becomes wasted precious real estate all around that area. Theres some videos out there that show this occurring,and I proved it to myself when the runs I used them in finished up.
Based on all that, I went back to the plastic pots.
From what a smart pot rep told me is that the smart pot stops root circling and the air that gets thru the pot causes the roots to prune themselves creating a more tighter dense root ball (kinda like topping a plant but with the roots). Due to that you are suppose to be able to use less soil for the same plant. Ex. 5 gallon now you can use 3 gallon. So... that may just be his sales pitch to me to buy them. I've used them and I'm 50/50 with them. Don't love em or hate em. But I know trying to transplant out of a smart pot is a messy nightmare.
 

mo841

Well-Known Member
I use the 7 gal smart pots. Never had an issue with them. I have a saucer under them that I can let them sit in water to soak it up.

I didn't really see any difference in growth between the smart pots or the buckets. I like them because they are a bit shorter than buckets.
 

backtracker

Well-Known Member
How smart are these pots, really? Watering is a complete nightmare, makes a mess and requires a lot more time. When watering a regular old pot it seems to take the water in evenly, with these smart pots it's soaked in some places and dry AF in others.

Think I'm going to ditch these after harvest. Anyone else have experience watering these things?
when you water make sure that the soil hasn't shrunk away from the side if it has press it down, same with a plastic pots and before you water use a spray bottle with a mix of yucca extract or molasses to wet the surface wait a little while then water, start watering on the edge then do the inner and don't let the surface get really dry because peat when dry repels water use a mulch like alfalfa to keep it moist.
 

mauricem00

Well-Known Member
I thought I liked them too until Doc and a few of us kicked that subject around. As it turns out, often with the fabric pots you'll see postmortem that the roots stopped as much as 5 inches in or so all the way around the circumference of the pot. As such it becomes wasted precious real estate all around that area. Theres some videos out there that show this occurring,and I proved it to myself when the runs I used them in finished up.
Based on all that, I went back to the plastic pots.
on my pots ive had roots grow thru the bottom into the drain table. like them better than plastic pots.
 

MediheaLed

Well-Known Member
Experienced 2 gal fabric pot user here. They are an improvement over plastic. Roots 5" from the inside? Nope, more like outside. Usually my root balls are rock solid, penetrating all throughout the pot, not all swirled up like in plastic. ( spring pots).
 

Lordhooha

Well-Known Member
Experienced 2 gal fabric pot user here. They are an improvement over plastic. Roots 5" from the inside? Nope, more like outside. Usually my root balls are rock solid, penetrating all throughout the pot, not all swirled up like in
Each to his own man! Looks like you got a watering ring set up which like in said I think would work nice with those style. Imy a hand waterer still so they are just not for me... maybe if I get something auto I'll break them out again.
i hand water, you need to change the way you water with these
 

Wisher2

Well-Known Member
I have used 1gal smart pots and pulled 4zips per plant with them
when I finished my run I couldn't pull the pot from the roots ball because the roots blew out of the pot and circled the fabric pot itself
what I didn't like was the fact that the fabric soaks in salts and holds onto them....

so each pot at the end was white with roots and salt
and I would run 10-15% runoff in a Drip to waste system

so for me....while they worked...I just didn't like how much they held onto the salts

back to plastic I went
 

MediheaLed

Well-Known Member
Yes, mine turn white and get hard (crusty) IF I don't soak them before next use. I run some florakleen before chop, helps too.
 
Top