400w HPS vs 3000w bestva LED

[upsidedownpotato]

Hi everyone,

This will be my second grow. Last grow I used a 400w HPS cooltube, and received a free 3000w bestva LED. I'm wondering if the led would be worth using over the HPS? I know that it's not 3000 actual watts, but it's pretty close to the same actual wattage of the HPS. I'm in a 2x4x5 tent if it matters.

I'm leaning towards HPS because I liked the results of last run, and I know practically nothing about LED. Hoping some more knowledgeable folks out there can help me out.

Thanks for any input/advice.

 

[Hobbes]

,

375 watts at the wall, and it's an old school blurple with what looks like lenses over the LED.

Not much of a light but you could put it on one end of your 4" tent so your 400 w hps will cover the rest.

.

 

[GBAUTO]

Agreed.
At best, the led is equal to the hps in output.

 

[upsidedownpotato]

I saw on Amazon it shows the led at 375w from the wall but their website has it at 465w plus or minus 5%. I'll go with the tried and true hps though. Too much heat will both

 

[Budzbuddha]

Neither -

Go strips / bars / boards - samsung - cree etc.
And a shoutout to CMH and timbergrowlight COBS


FIFY

 

[upsidedownpotato]

Neither -

Go strips / bars / boards - samsung - cree etc.
And a shoutout to CMH and timbergrowlight COBS


FIFY

Appreciate the input but I'm not going to get another light. HPS definitely works really well and I had great results (over 1g/watt). I am only wondering if it'd be worth swapping with the mentioned LED.

 

[Bukvičák]

Appreciate the input but I'm not going to get another light. HPS definitely works really well and I had great results (over 1g/watt). I am only wondering if it'd be worth swapping with the mentioned LED.

Maybe in summer

 

[Markshomegrown]

400w HPS can work really well with the right reflector (medium adjust-a-wing fully open)
this will work really well in the 4ft x 2ft

 

[OneHitDone]

400w HPS can work really well with the right reflector (medium adjust-a-wing fully open)
this will work really well in the 4ft x 2ft

Which orientation would you hang the lamp - lengthwise or side to side in the tent?

 

[upsidedownpotato]

Which orientation would you hang the lamp - lengthwise or side to side in the tent?

Since the tent is a rectangle, surely it only makes sense to hang it parallel (long ways).

 

[Markshomegrown]

Which orientation would you hang the lamp - lengthwise or side to side in the tent?

one of my old setups, works really well

 

[OneHitDone]

one of my old setups, works really well
View attachment 5074443

Yup, sideways for better coverage on the 4' dimension