Do ANY dogs go to doggie heaven?

chewberto

Well-Known Member
Well the question has finally been answered! After doing some research into the human body losing 21 grams at the time of death, I found this little article!

"It turns out that the only source for the 21 gram figure is a discredited study carried out in 1907 by a Haverhill, Massachusetts, doctor by the name of Duncan MacDougall. He managed (apparently overcoming any ethical qualms over human experimentation) to put six dying people on a bed equipped with sensitive springs, and claimed to have observed a sudden loss of weight – about ¾ of an ounce – at the exact moment of their death. Having reasoned that such loss could not be explained by bowel movements or evaporation, he concluded he must have measured the weight of the soul. A follow-up experiment also showed that dogs (which were healthy, so they were probably poisoned on purpose by the good doctor) don't seem to suffer the same sort of loss, therefore they don't have souls (sorry, you canine lovers)." http://rationallyspeaking.blogspot.com/2007/03/does-soul-weigh-21-grams.html?m=1
 

MFB

Active Member
Maybe the 21 grams was weed the doctor took off the body. Figured hell, he won't need it. Or it could be the air leaving the lungs. But reading the article I see its all horse shit. I wonder why other scientists of the day didn't discredit him.
 

kinddiesel

Well-Known Member
I own the doggy day cares in Michigan . I have to tell you my job is yes dogs go to heaven, dogs dream we dream . so were the same . or the dog might turn human lol, depends
 

curious2garden

Well-Known Mod
Staff member
Well the question has finally been answered! After doing some research into the human body losing 21 grams at the time of death, I found this little article!

"It turns out that the only source for the 21 gram figure is a discredited study carried out in 1907 by a Haverhill, Massachusetts, doctor by the name of Duncan MacDougall. He managed (apparently overcoming any ethical qualms over human experimentation) to put six dying people on a bed equipped with sensitive springs, and claimed to have observed a sudden loss of weight – about ¾ of an ounce – at the exact moment of their death. Having reasoned that such loss could not be explained by bowel movements or evaporation, he concluded he must have measured the weight of the soul. A follow-up experiment also showed that dogs (which were healthy, so they were probably poisoned on purpose by the good doctor) don't seem to suffer the same sort of loss, therefore they don't have souls (sorry, you canine lovers)." http://rationallyspeaking.blogspot.com/2007/03/does-soul-weigh-21-grams.html?m=1
He did not control for insensate losses among other things. Experimental design is only as good as our science. I've not seen any loss at death on the patients who died on beds with scales and respirators, yes I did look cause I'm curious after all, but again that's merely anecdotal. Further that study would be a toughie to design and as CN said impossible to get past the bioethics committee (party poopers).
 
Top