I'm not arguing either or, more tools in the tool box as they say. Rather looking for something that can be put together by someone of limited mobility, scavenging skills, or in an area sparse of common yard wastes like leaves or grass clippings and space for big piles. Yet doesn't want to buy weak premade compost and wants ANOTHER tool besides VC.
If that makes sense.
The best thing for anyone who doesn't have one is to "start a compost". It's what plants crave. Just gotta figure out how to wedge one into your lifestyle. It takes months to get up and running, but it's just what you need.
I deal with a crappy plastic bin.
Food and plant scraps in the top (along with some basic organic plant foods), magic comes out the bottom. There really isn't anything better than that.
A small household so all vegetable and plant waste goes in the top. You don't need a lot of stuff. Gives you a reason to buy and eat more vegetables and fruit - because the waste is a bonus.
No plastic compost tub? Bodge something together from two old pallets, or treee limbs and and stuff. Or drill out a big plastic storage tub. Or buy a pair of those stupid compost tumblers.
You just need a couple of square feet of bare ground.
If you don't have the space think about your community - neighbourhood compost bins are a thing these days.