removing fan leaves in flower

citeh

Well-Known Member
I'm a scientist. Let's setup a fund for every post arguing for or against defoliation, donate a dollar to my electric bill and I'll run the experiments.
 

BM9AGS

Well-Known Member
I'm a scientist. Let's setup a fund for every post arguing for or against defoliation, donate a dollar to my electric bill and I'll run the experiments.
Ya know what. Fuck it. I have 26 growing and 4 are clones. I'll strip one bitch in the name of newbs.

I know there's a side by some somewhere on this forum of a plant getting striped and another not. But can't find it.
 

Lucky Luke

Well-Known Member
Ya know what. Fuck it. I have 26 growing and 4 are clones. I'll strip one bitch in the name of newbs.

I know there's a side by some somewhere on this forum of a plant getting striped and another not. But can't find it.
Rip all those leaves off good and proper!

Nothing defoliates like Agent Orange!
 

citeh

Well-Known Member
Ya know what. Fuck it. I have 26 growing and 4 are clones. I'll strip one bitch in the name of newbs.

I know there's a side by some somewhere on this forum of a plant getting striped and another not. But can't find it.
n of 3 in your control group and n 1 experimental, should we discuss p values?
 

Dumme

Well-Known Member
For pro-defoliation...
Well, like any Thesis, it prudent to take steps. Generally those steps are:
2016-07-23 01.05.52.jpg

You can skip the Literature Review, as there is none, or its already all contradictory to the Thesis at hand.
 

Lucky Luke

Well-Known Member
Im interested in seeing the results.

I prune roses and people prune tomato plants. But ive never heard of people cutting leaves off of them.

I find it a bit strange that the people who do cut the leaves off then have to do it over and over again as the plant keeps replacing them. Isnt that a waste of nutrients and energy better spend elsewhere?

Maybe it will work out the same as defoliating the hairs on your groin. May make your dick look bigger but its still as small as it was before you did it.
 

Dumme

Well-Known Member
Im interested in seeing the results.

I prune roses and people prune tomato plants. But ive never heard of people cutting leaves off of them.

I find it a bit strange that the people who do cut the leaves off then have to do it over and over again as the plant keeps replacing them. Isnt that a waste of nutrients and energy better spend elsewhere?

Maybe it will work out the same as defoliating the hairs on your groin. May make your dick look bigger but its still as small as it was before you did it.
Plants require leaves as that's where G3P is made for Carbohydrates (sugars). Not sure how the pro-defoliation believers think the plant is grown...
 

Budley Doright

Well-Known Member
Wasnt trying to jump on you budley misreadyour original post. Was just laying out science for some folks
Ya my post was confusing but as far as pulling leaves, I did it 40 years ago, that's what "they" told us to do, and still try it once every few years and still hasn't improved my grow. But if people want and feel it does, well have at'er. It's a plant, only a plant, it doesn't matter how you grow it really as long as it makes you happy :).
 

MichiganMedGrower

Well-Known Member
image.jpeg I have tried both quite a few times. I admit only from seed. But different strains all the time.

She had almost every leaf right up to harvest. I tried my hardest to keep her healthy but she was a little rough at 12 weeks.

My average yeild has doubled since I keep the leaves healthy as long as I can.

image.jpeg image.jpeg
 

MichiganMedGrower

Well-Known Member
Don't know why the last pic showed first but it is all the same bush.

I only pick necrotic leaves. If they are hanging on tight the plant is using them.
 

Budley Doright

Well-Known Member
View attachment 3739206 I have tried both quite a few times. I admit only from seed. But different strains all the time.

She had almost every leaf right up to harvest. I tried my hardest to keep her healthy but she was a little rough at 12 weeks.

My average yeild has doubled since I keep the leaves healthy as long as I can.

View attachment 3739203 View attachment 3739204
That's the key right there, keep em healthy and promote a good root mass. When people say the leaves fall off naturally anyways .... Well it's been my experience that they only fall off when unhappy and there is a problem. They just don't jump ship when they feel the need lol.
 

VTMi'kmaq

Well-Known Member
Before you cut off leaves to allow light to buds, you should know how efficient the buds are at photosynthesis, temp. regulation, hormone production, and gas exchange. Cutting off random leaves probably isn't going to make your plant explode in growth.
Kinda the same way cutting off an Olympic sprinters leg would make him a shit load lighter, probably not a whole lot faster.
That analogy made my nuts drop.
 

MichiganMedGrower

Well-Known Member
I have to say some strains persist to yellow some leaves while flowering no matter what but the plant basically stalls and tries to rebuild when pruned or defoliated.

when I started out I defoliated gradually through flower and we all agreed that the buds were growing faster. Problem is. My scale says different every time.
 
Top