Going from HPS to LED. Worth it?

[Porky101]

If you are still going on about something from yesterday, yes, very.

You are right, I should have responded way sooner, my apologies.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

You are right, I should have responded way sooner, my apologies.

Or maybe not at all? Because you have nothing to prove? If you feel you do, you need thicker skin.

 

[Porky101]

In fact, the fact that you feel you have something to prove to me shows exactly how defensive you are being. You have nothing to prove to anyone.

It's not to prove anything to you mate, you dont know what your talking about, as PROVEN by my photo.

You are upset that I have shown you up, that your advice is wrong and now you are upset.

Your only defense is to say im being defensive...lol

Im doing this purely because I want to help another grower and perhaps if he can see that your advice is bad advice, then he may choose someone else to take info from.

Trust me...forums has a LOT of bad info on it....and its only getting worse.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

It not to prove anything to you mate, you dont know what your talking about, as PROVEN by my photo.

You are upset that I have shown you up. That your advice is wrong and now you are upset.

No, your current photo shows the issue is resolved. The other photo proves you were just barely getting N toxic, but my concern was for the overwatering, not really the N as much.

I definitely know what I'm talking about. Those finger leaves were curling sideways and were extremely dark.

I'm not upset about anything. I was just trying to help you.

 

[Porky101]

No, your current photo shows the issue is resolved. The other photo proves you were just barely getting N toxic, but my concern was for the overwatering, not really the N as much.

I definitely know what I'm talking about. Those finger leaves were curling sideways and were extremely dark.

I'm not upset about anything. I was just trying to help you.

I am not sure if you READ what I wrote YESTURDAY, I am growing in COCO and PERLITE. That information was a GIVEN. You cannot over water in coco.....yet you still say its over watered??


Also, how can N toxicity be resolved in a day? By saying that you are contradicting yourself. Yesturday it has N toxicity and is over watered, today the issue is fully resolved??

 

[Olive Drab Green]

Here, here's proof I was right:



See? That is your picture, followed by a reference.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

Plants don't just claw like that for no reason, man. And the plants were dark. N tox effects older foliage first. It wasn't severe, it was mild.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

And you can overwater coco if you are watering it too frequently. Coco holds water for a pretty good amount of time. You must be watering it too soon.

 

[Yodaweed]

And you can overwater coco if you are watering it too frequently. Coco holds water for a pretty good amount of time. You must be watering it too soon.

You sure about that? I used an auto watering system when I ran coco in a 4x4 flood tray, constant water/nutes, huge yields, very healthy plants, watered with nutes 2-3 times a day or whenever they would become a little dry.

 

[Porky101]

What you are circling is not claw....its the effect of gravity on the leaf and lack of light...

 

[Porky101]

And you can overwater coco if you are watering it too frequently. Coco holds water for a pretty good amount of time. You must be watering it too soon.

No you cant.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

This here is an overwatered cannabis plant with droopy leaves curling in in itself. And do you notice the yellow, chlorotic leaves at the bottom? Because yours is showing that, too.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

No you cant.

Of course you can. Dude, I have always grown in coco. You can overwater coco by watering too frequently, because coco HOLDS WATER. It's that simple. You aren't waiting long enough between waterings.

 

[Porky101]

View attachment 3826154

This here is an overwatered cannabis plant with droopy leaves curling in in itself. And do you notice the yellow, chlorotic leaves at the bottom? Because yours is showing that, too.

Mine is showing one leaf that is yellow, I have already TOLD you that it is a Magnesium deficiency, if you never knew that already...

 

[Yodaweed]

Of course you can. Dude, I have always grown in coco. You can overwater coco by watering too frequently, because coco HOLDS WATER. It's that simple. You aren't waiting long enough between waterings.

I've never heard of someone over watering in coco, unless you used pure coco and even then...

 

[Porky101]

Of course you can. Dude, I have always grown in coco. You can overwater coco by watering too frequently, because coco HOLDS WATER. It's that simple. You aren't waiting long enough between waterings.

Overwatering a plant has nothing to do with how much water a medium holds. it has to do with how much AIR it holds. COCO always holds air. So you cannot overwater.

With your logic that means you can over water in DWC.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

"Overwatered Marijuana Plants

• Drooping / Curling is the first sign of overwaterd marijuana plants
  
  
• Plants start drooping after watering
  
  
• Leaves are firm and curled down all the way from the stem to the leaf
  
  
• Will eventually lead to leaf yellowing and other signs of nutrient problems if not corrected
  
  "
  

 

[Yodaweed]

"Overwatered Marijuana Plants

• Drooping / Curling is the first sign of overwaterd marijuana plants
  
  
• Plants start drooping after watering
  
  
• Leaves are firm and curled down all the way from the stem to the leaf
  
  
• Will eventually lead to leaf yellowing and other signs of nutrient problems if not corrected
  
  "

That's for soil grows noob, coco is a hydroponics substitute.

 

[Olive Drab Green]

I've never heard of someone over watering in coco, unless you used pure coco and even then...

If you aren't letting it dry out before watering again, you can and will overwater coco.

 

[Yodaweed]

If you aren't letting it dry out before watering again, you can and will overwater coco.

You can grow coco like soil but it's not optimal, you got a lot to learn.