The only reason the Amish avoided disaster is that they live in cloistered communities that are surrounded by people who are immunized against a wide variety of diseases. Also the public health system protects them, like with emergency covid vaccination programs. Most people today know nothing of the horrors of the many childhood diseases that killed millions of infants, toddlers and children a hundred years ago. There were a host of killers that people know nothing about and now feel safe enough to believe and spread bullshit that continues to kill people and especially children. It might be different if the antivaccers had any evidence at all, any, but they continue to murder people like Trump did with covid.
It makes the presumption that doctors and scientists are maliciously lying to you with no evidence of such. I have no problem calling the likes of Trump liars to their faces, but would never do so to a person of honor and integrity, even behind their backs. People need to start having and living by values, it helps deal with the malicious disinformation we are inundated with. Antivaccers are fear driven, ignorant child murders, that's all they are, nothing more.