HPA DIY first system question/ newbie

Wastei

Well-Known Member
I didnt give you the full picture here.

You need to start with the nozzle pressure you want to run at. Those tefins should make ok to good droplet sizes at anywhere from about 80 PSI to 100 PSI. Higher is better because the droplets will be smaller.

But - you need to have a good spread between the minimum pressure in your tank and the max pressure. Otherwise the pump will be cycling too often.

You need to set the pressure reducer/regulator to the pressure you want the nozzle to run at. Lets say thats 80 PSI.

That means you want the accumulator tank set to have a MINIMUM pressure of at least 80 PSI. The pump should turn ON when the pressure drops to 80 PSI.

You want the tank MAXIMUM pressure to be as far above that 80 PSI as you can get it so the pump will cycle less often - BUT - still below the safe upper limit of the tank. If your tank has a max rated working pressure of 100, then dont go over that.

You also need to look at your solenoids. You dont want to run them too close to their maximum rated pressure. Most of the ones I have looked at are rated to about 100-115 PSI. Its best to run them a good 10% lower than the max pressure.
Typical recommendations is to run 3 psi below set pump pressure in the ackumulator tank. I'm planning on running my system on 110psi on the pump with 107psi set on the ackumulator tank. Pressure switch at 100psi.

I don't currently have a pressure gauge but I bet my system currently run at 80-90psi. It grows some trees for sure. Everything from 80-130psi is gonna work but the higher the better.
 

Larry3215

Well-Known Member
the idea for a solenoid for each sprayer that's a great idea , maybe one day when I figure out how to build my own controller lol , one thing at a time.
Any cheap digital timer can run several solenoids ast the same time. Most of the timers can handle at least 10 amps, and most solenoids are about 0.5 amps, so you dont need a special controller.

I use these cheap timers and run up to 4 solenoids per timer. They can handle as many as 20 of the solenoids I use.


They are cheap enough you can use one per solenoid if you want. I actually prefer to do it that way - with one timer per solenoid and one solenoid per nozzle. The timers are never perfectly in sync, so your nozzles will fire at slightly different times - which spreads out the mist cycle better.

Its very important if you want fuzzy roots to control the quality of the mist cycle as much as possible. That means you really do need one solenoid per nozzle and you need to keep the solenoid as close tot he nozzle as possible. Useing one timer to control them all or one timer for each solenoid doesnt make a huge difference.

I was wondering is it fine to use a sediment filter like this one or does it some how filter out essential minerals ?
Hydronix ICF-10Q Inline Coconut Filter 2000 Gal, 2-Inch OD X 10-Inch Length, 1/4-Inch Quick Connect https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B00D04BXX6/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_MBUaGbGF7ES26
Thats not needed and may remove some of your nutes.

I use a normal stainless filter with a 200 mesh screen. Have it between the rez and the pump. This one is cheap and works well.


I prefer the larger Y type filters so you dont have to clean them as often, but they are more $$.
 

Larry3215

Well-Known Member
Typical recommendations is to run 3 psi below set pump pressure in the ackumulator tank. I'm planning on running my system on 110psi on the pump with 107psi set on the ackumulator tank. Pressure switch at 100psi.

I don't currently have a pressure gauge but I bet my system currently run at 80-90psi. It grows some trees for sure. Everything from 80-130psi is gonna work but the higher the better.
If you are talking about the pressure for the bladder inside the tank being set to 3PSI below the operating pressure, I agree.

When you say the pressure switch is set to 100 PSI, is that the cut ON pressure - the pressure the pump turns ON at, or the pressure the pump turns OFF at?

Im missing something either way. If thats the turn ON pressure, then you have a very narrow range and the pump will cycle very often. if its the cut OFF pressure, then how do you get to 110 PSI?

Sorry, I havent had all my coffee yet ;)
 

Wastei

Well-Known Member
If you are talking about the pressure for the bladder inside the tank being set to 3PSI below the operating pressure, I agree.

When you say the pressure switch is set to 100 PSI, is that the cut ON pressure - the pressure the pump turns ON at, or the pressure the pump turns OFF at?

Im missing something either way. If thats the turn ON pressure, then you have a very narrow range and the pump will cycle very often. if its the cut OFF pressure, then how do you get to 110 PSI?

Sorry, I havent had all my coffee yet ;)
ON pressure lol. Having a range of 100-110psi would be optimal but like you wrote I may have to adjust this depending on ackumulator tank size and plant count. I may even use 80-110. I think the max pressure for the pump is 110psi but like everything I have to try it out for myself.

I've read contradicting numbers on 8852 so I'm not really not sure how my pumps gonna perform yet. I've seen 125psi as max pressure and 110psi, so I'm out in the blue here. Haven't received my pump yet, so I may change those numbers depending how the system/mist performs and look. Cheers!
 

Rdubz

Well-Known Member
ON pressure lol. Having a range of 100-110psi would be optimal but like you wrote I may have to adjust this depending on ackumulator tank size and plant count. I may even use 80-110. I think the max pressure for the pump is 110psi but like everything I have to try it out for myself.

I've read contradicting numbers on 8852 so I'm not really not sure how my pumps gonna perform yet. I've seen 125psi as max pressure and 110psi, so I'm out in the blue here. Haven't received my pump yet, so I may change those numbers depending how the system/mist performs and look. Cheers!
I have the "8800" pumps and The most I was able to get was 120psi and it's not easy to do that it's a Ballance act with pressure switch and like I said before I was confused on how to get it all dialed in I broke 2 pressure sensors trying but finally figured it out , it definitely a learning experience and as @Larry3215 explained now it all makes sense and I didn't even know about having a pressure regulator that I feel is one of the most important pieces to it ! But regardless I'm still learning and will never stop there is just too much to know
 

Larry3215

Well-Known Member
ON pressure lol. Having a range of 100-110psi would be optimal but like you wrote I may have to adjust this depending on ackumulator tank size and plant count. I may even use 80-110. I think the max pressure for the pump is 110psi but like everything I have to try it out for myself.
Yeah, the accumulator tank serves two purposes. The larger the tank, the less often the pump has to cycle, which means it will last longer. It also allows you to add the pressure reducer/regulator which means you can have a more uniform spray.

The ideal condition in any HPA or AA grow would be to have an absolutely uniform mist, that was perfectly and evenly distributed all through your root chamber, and that never faded away or got stronger. Your roots would be absolutely happy if they could always have the perfect, unchanging, mist environment.

Goldilocks in other words - not too much and not too little, but just right all the time :)

Obviously we cant do that with our current tech, so we have to do the best we can. Part of that is having each mist cycle be the same as the last one. That means you need to have the same pressure each time - or as close as possible.

Your situation is different than what @Rdubz and I are after. We want fuzzy roots above all else, and that requires a higher standard of operation. Since you dont care about fuzzy roots, you can get away with things we cant.

I've read contradicting numbers on 8852 so I'm not really not sure how my pumps gonna perform yet. I've seen 125psi as max pressure and 110psi, so I
I have the "8800" pumps and The most I was able to get was 120psi and it's not easy to do that it's a Ballance act with pressure switch and like I said before I was confused on how to get it all dialed in I broke 2 pressure sensors trying but finally figured it out , it definitely a learning experience and as @Larry3215 explained now it all makes sense and I didn't even know about having a pressure regulator that I feel is one of the most important pieces to it ! But regardless I'm still learning and will never stop there is just too much to know
Aquatec specs are all over the place. I spent weeks emailing their tech dept asking questions because the listed specs on different web sites were not consistent at all. Turns out even aquatec doesnt know what the true specs are. Part of that is not all 8800 pumps have the same cut off pressure setting. Its in the model numbers.

One thing that is often confusing is that the "pressure adjustment" thats on the pump itself isnt really a pressure adjustment - its a by-pass adjustment. You are actually adjusting a bleed valve that lets hi pressure bleed back to the low pressure side. This works along with the exterior pressure switch. The maximum pressure is actually determined by which one of the two is set to the LOWEST setting. You can actually run some models up to 160 PSI IIRC.

In any case, with an accumulator tank, the idea situation is to have the maximum spread between the hi and low cut off points.
 

Wastei

Well-Known Member
Yeah, the accumulator tank serves two purposes. The larger the tank, the less often the pump has to cycle, which means it will last longer. It also allows you to add the pressure reducer/regulator which means you can have a more uniform spray.

The ideal condition in any HPA or AA grow would be to have an absolutely uniform mist, that was perfectly and evenly distributed all through your root chamber, and that never faded away or got stronger. Your roots would be absolutely happy if they could always have the perfect, unchanging, mist environment.

Goldilocks in other words - not too much and not too little, but just right all the time :)

Obviously we cant do that with our current tech, so we have to do the best we can. Part of that is having each mist cycle be the same as the last one. That means you need to have the same pressure each time - or as close as possible.

Your situation is different than what @Rdubz and I are after. We want fuzzy roots above all else, and that requires a higher standard of operation. Since you dont care about fuzzy roots, you can get away with things we cant.

Aquatec specs are all over the place. I spent weeks emailing their tech dept asking questions because the listed specs on different web sites were not consistent at all. Turns out even aquatec doesnt know what the true specs are. Part of that is not all 8800 pumps have the same cut off pressure setting. Its in the model numbers.

One thing that is often confusing is that the "pressure adjustment" thats on the pump itself isnt really a pressure adjustment - its a by-pass adjustment. You are actually adjusting a bleed valve that lets hi pressure bleed back to the low pressure side. This works along with the exterior pressure switch. The maximum pressure is actually determined by which one of the two is set to the LOWEST setting. You can actually run some models up to 160 PSI IIRC.

In any case, with an accumulator tank, the idea situation is to have the maximum spread between the hi and low cut off points.
Yeah the specs and model numbers is a fucking mess.

Yes I'm more after stability, overall plant health and growth speed. I don't really care about fuzzy roots, I want big and healthy lateral growth. I grow flowers to medicate, not roots lol.

The only time you really have time to look at the roots is at harvest time. But I can see the point, but in all honestly I think roots are better left alone IMO. Cheers!
 

Wastei

Well-Known Member
Im confused about a couple of things.

Is the pressure switch the solenoid that opens to allow water to get to the nozzle?

Is the shutoff valve just a manual shut off valve or is this the solenoid?

When you say its on and misting - you mean the its misting full time - no on/off with the solenoid?

If so, the pump is working the way it is supposed to work. It has an internal pressure switch that turns the pump off when it reaches the hi setting - which could be anywhere from about 60-150 PSI. There should be an adjustment screw somewhere on the pump.

Anyway, the pump will turn off when that pressure is reached, then it will turn back ON when the pressure drops to the lower setting.

There are two things you need to do to eliminate that cycling.

1) Add an accumulator tank.
2) Add a pressure reducer right after the accumulator tank and before the solenoid that controls the nozzles.

The pressure reducer should be set to a pressure less than the pump minimum pressure.

This is the one I used when I was doing HPA. Its cheap, but works well.

This is the accumulator tank I used.

Make sure the pumps max pressure is less than the accumulator tank max pressure. That tank is safe to 150 PSI, so you would set the pump to about 125 PSI, then set the pressure deducer to anything under the cut ON setting of the pump.

If you do that, your nozzles will always have an even, constant pressure, and your pump will only need to run every hour or more depending on the size of the tank, number of nozzles. Those pumps are not really designed to run full time.
From my understanding the pressure switch is what actually turns the pump on and off. It is first connected to the power supply then to the pump acting as a braker for the pump.

The screw on the top of pump must be for pass through psi setting. Found this:
Screenshot_20210117-140736_1.png
 

Wastei

Well-Known Member
Even more confused. We'll see what pressure switch I actually receive first of all. It's always this sort of information hunt regarding components, settings and stuff, but it's all a part of this hobby. You learn a lot with this hobby. Cheers!
 

Rdubz

Well-Known Member
From my understanding the pressure switch is what actually turns the pump on and off. It is first connected to the power supply then to the pump acting as a braker for the pump.

The screw on the top of pump must be for pass through psi setting. Found this:
View attachment 4799102
wow that's a good find I wish I seen it few days ago but yes this is part of the experience lol , so I have the 80 psi ones and I feel they are best ones for me since I'm not going any where near that 150psi ,

Yeah the specs and model numbers is a fucking mess.

Yes I'm more after stability, overall plant health and growth speed. I don't really care about fuzzy roots, I want big and healthy lateral growth. I grow flowers to medicate, not roots lol.

The only time you really have time to look at the roots is at harvest time. But I can see the point, but in all honestly I think roots are better left alone IMO. Cheers!
For sure , FYI I'm not a new grower here just new in HPA but yes my goal is to push the envelope with the best medicine I can make for the ones that need it the most , I have been running flood and drain tables for Years now, That was all I knew and now I'm in love with everything about HPA . Been researching is for about 1 year before I started Building anything , been a journey and now since Joining this community I have learned more in this short time Than I would of on my own I know that.

Now I'm trying to research making redundancies in the system , 2 pressure switches 2 pumps and anything else that would be a failsafe.
 

Larry3215

Well-Known Member
From my understanding the pressure switch is what actually turns the pump on and off. It is first connected to the power supply then to the pump acting as a braker for the pump.

The screw on the top of pump must be for pass through psi setting. Found this:
Yes. Thats exactly what I was saying above. The by-pass setting on the pump limits the max pressure the pump can reach - no matter what the pressure switch is set to. You may need to adjust both to get the range of pressures you want.

For example, the by-pass could be set to 80 PSI, and even if you set the pressure switch to 100 PSI, the pressure will never go above 80 PSI. The reverse it true too. If you set the pressure switch to 80 PSI, and the by -pass is set to 100 PSI, the system will never go above 80 PSI. Its the LOWEST one of the two that determines the max pressure.

I used to have a table explaining what the model number letters actually mean as far as max pressure, etc, but I cant find it. It should be on the Aquatec site somewhere.

I saw some people early on were ditching the Aquatec pressure switchs and using a different one - so they could get a wider pressure range from minimum to max. Also for reliability. There were some reports of the switches failing - in some cases ON - which means the pump just keeps running and running.... Mostly they seem pretty decent though.

If it was me, I would go for the PSW-x100, then set the max pressure to just under the safe pressure for the accumulator tank, then set the pressure reducer/regulator to what ever your nozzles like best as far as good hang time on the mist. Also being sure your solenoids are not pushed too hard.

Now I'm trying to research making redundancies in the system , 2 pressure switches 2 pumps and anything else that would be a failsafe.
Thats not a bad idea, but you dont need to worry that your roots will instantly die if the system looses power or a pump fails. Roots can survive several hours easily with no misting. More than long enough for you to replace a pump or switch.

My root chamber is made from fabric grow pots. Thats to keep the chamber cool enough. The upside AND downside to using fabric pots is that water evaporates through the fabric.

The UP-side is that I get free evaporative cooling of my root chamber. I actually have to heat my root chamber even in sumer.

The DOWN side is that evaporation means my roots will dry out faster if I loose power or if a component fails - or if I am 'growing while stoned' and forget to turn the timer back ON after doing some maintenance.

I have gone as long as 14 hours with no spray before I realized what happened. The roots did suffer damage, but recovered in about a week. The plants showed signs of damage, but survived just fine. That was actually one of my best harvests too.

If you are using a plastic root chamber that is mostly sealed, you will be able to go much longer than I can.
 

Wastei

Well-Known Member
Yes. Thats exactly what I was saying above. The by-pass setting on the pump limits the max pressure the pump can reach - no matter what the pressure switch is set to. You may need to adjust both to get the range of pressures you want.

For example, the by-pass could be set to 80 PSI, and even if you set the pressure switch to 100 PSI, the pressure will never go above 80 PSI. The reverse it true too. If you set the pressure switch to 80 PSI, and the by -pass is set to 100 PSI, the system will never go above 80 PSI. Its the LOWEST one of the two that determines the max pressure.

I used to have a table explaining what the model number letters actually mean as far as max pressure, etc, but I cant find it. It should be on the Aquatec site somewhere.

I saw some people early on were ditching the Aquatec pressure switchs and using a different one - so they could get a wider pressure range from minimum to max. Also for reliability. There were some reports of the switches failing - in some cases ON - which means the pump just keeps running and running.... Mostly they seem pretty decent though.

If it was me, I would go for the PSW-x100, then set the max pressure to just under the safe pressure for the accumulator tank, then set the pressure reducer/regulator to what ever your nozzles like best as far as good hang time on the mist. Also being sure your solenoids are not pushed too hard.



Thats not a bad idea, but you dont need to worry that your roots will instantly die if the system looses power or a pump fails. Roots can survive several hours easily with no misting. More than long enough for you to replace a pump or switch.

My root chamber is made from fabric grow pots. Thats to keep the chamber cool enough. The upside AND downside to using fabric pots is that water evaporates through the fabric.

The UP-side is that I get free evaporative cooling of my root chamber. I actually have to heat my root chamber even in sumer.

The DOWN side is that evaporation means my roots will dry out faster if I loose power or if a component fails - or if I am 'growing while stoned' and forget to turn the timer back ON after doing some maintenance.

I have gone as long as 14 hours with no spray before I realized what happened. The roots did suffer damage, but recovered in about a week. The plants showed signs of damage, but survived just fine. That was actually one of my best harvests too.

If you are using a plastic root chamber that is mostly sealed, you will be able to go much longer than I can.
I agree on most things but if the pressure switch stops working the pump won't run. That's at least how my Seaflo pump works. I've read about people installing them without pressure switch flooding the basement. Lol.

I don't think the reducer you posted is going to work. It's just down regulate relative to the input pressure, it's also with 1/4 not 3/8". If you would to install a step down pressure reducer it would have to be digtially controlled IMO, otherwise it doesn't make any sense. You will still have a range of pressure relative to pump settings, not constant.

Having a pressure range is better for pump reliability, say 100-120. Droplet size doesn't differ that much between 90-110, it's more important with a uniform cycle and amount of water being sprayed IMO.

I've ordered the PSW-3100. Cheers!
 

Rdubz

Well-Known Member
I agree on most things but if the pressure switch stops working the pump won't run. That's at least how my Seaflo pump works. I've read about people installing them without pressure switch flooding the basement. Lol.

I don't think the reducer you posted is going to work. It's just down regulate relative to the input pressure, it's also with 1/4 not 3/8". If you would to install a step down pressure reducer it would have to be digtially controlled IMO, otherwise it doesn't make any sense. You will still have a range of pressure relative to pump settings, not constant.

Having a pressure range is better for pump reliability, say 100-120. Droplet size doesn't differ that much between 90-110, it's more important with a uniform cycle and amount of water being sprayed IMO.

I've ordered the PSW-3100. Cheers!
Are you using 3/8" tubing for everything? Or is that the main run and then down sizing to 1/4"?
 

Rdubz

Well-Known Member
Main lines are 3/8", down to 1/4" by the solenoid valves/nozzles. Cheers!
That's actually really smart , so I have the aquatec pumps 8800 that are equiped with 1/4" QC . Did u get your pump with the 3/8" inlet and outlet or did u use upside fitting ? Sorry I'm just asking for my own purposes if I where to do that in my case going from the 1/4" at the pump and converting it to the 3/8" would it make a difference or does it make no sense and I should just buy the right pump?

FYI this is more for future Upgradeability
 

Larry3215

Well-Known Member
I agree on most things but if the pressure switch stops working the pump won't run.
True. I was only talking about your ability to set the max pressure on the pump and the pressure differential range.

I don't think the reducer you posted is going to work. It's just down regulate relative to the input pressure, it's also with 1/4 not 3/8". If you would to install a step down pressure reducer it would have to be digtially controlled IMO, otherwise it doesn't make any sense. You will still have a range of pressure relative to pump settings, not constant.
LOL That pressure reducer worked just fine for me.
0122191037a.jpg0130191052.jpg

That is a single C99 plant grown with that reducer and 4 HPA nozzles. Stem was 2 1/8" in diameter at the base. Over 1200 gms dry weight yield from one plant in a 7.3 sq ft tent The white - fuzzy - roots nearly filled a 56 gallon root chamber.


I dont think you understand how this is supposed to work, but remember - we want fuzzy roots.

First - this wont work well at all unless you are using an accumulator tank. Second, you must always have MORE pressure built up in the accumulator tank than what the nozzles are running at. Thats why you use a pressure reducer. The pump pressure settings are supposed to make sure two things happen. The tank always has that higher pressure and it keeps the pump from cycling so often.

Droplet size doesn't differ that much between 90-110, it's more important with a uniform cycle and amount of water being sprayed IMO.
This is absolutely not true.

The pressure reducer is there for only one reason - to keep the nozzle pressure as CONSTANT as possible. Thats because pressure variations make a HUGE difference in the quality of the mist. Droplet size is directly related to the pressure. Its the pressure and only the pressure that determines droplet size for any given nozzle. Lower pressures = larger droplets.

If your goal is to get fuzzy roots, then you need to control the nozzle pressure as precisely as possible. Allowing the nozzle pressure to vary from 80 to 100 PSI means you will be making a very wide range of droplets. The largest ones will be wasted nutes and will inhibit fuzzy hairs from growing. The smallest may be too small to do the job properly. Very small droplets - 5 microns and smaller - are considered "dry" and dont transfer enough water to keep roots healthy.

This is also why you want ADV's (anti-drip valves) on the nozzles if possible, and a separate solenoid for each nozzle, and keep it as close to the nozzle as possible.

All of these things work together to help you have control over the droplet size and the resulting mist quality.

Again, you might not care about mist quality or droplet sizes or hang time, but remember - we want fuzzy roots. To get fuzzy roots you need correctly sized droplets in a mist that hangs around for a minimum of 1 minute and preferably longer.

There is nothing wrong with smooth roots, but fuzzy roots are a step up.

Every single detail I have been talking about is directed towards that single goal of creating a mist environment that will allow fuzzy roots to grow. Fuzzy roots are the cats meow :)

That's actually really smart , so I have the aquatec pumps 8800 that are equiped with 1/4" QC . Did u get your pump with the 3/8" inlet and outlet or did u use upside fitting ? Sorry I'm just asking for my own purposes if I where to do that in my case going from the 1/4" at the pump and converting it to the 3/8" would it make a difference or does it make no sense and I should just buy the right pump?

FYI this is more for future Upgradeability
For a smallish to medium grow - say up to 30 or 40 nozzles with a flow rate of aprox 1 GPH each, the tubing size doesnt matter as far as function. You will not see any significant pressure drops that effect the nozzle performance. Even if you had a large grow with 40 nozzles, you could just increase the pressure reducer setting slightly to off set any slight drop. The flow rate is too low for it to be a serious factor. 1/4" will work just as well as 3/8".

The difference will be felt in your wallet though if you dont try to keep all the components with the same size fittings. Reducers and adapters can easily end up costing more than all the rest of your plumbing combined. If your pump is 1/4", then try to get solenoids, nozzles, valves, filters, regulators, gauges, etc etc all with 1/4". Other than that, it doesnt matter either way.
 

Rdubz

Well-Known Member
True. I was only talking about your ability to set the max pressure on the pump and the pressure differential range.



LOL That pressure reducer worked just fine for me.
View attachment 4800805View attachment 4800806

That is a single C99 plant grown with that reducer and 4 HPA nozzles. Stem was 2 1/8" in diameter at the base. Over 1200 gms dry weight yield from one plant in a 7.3 sq ft tent The white - fuzzy - roots nearly filled a 56 gallon root chamber.


I dont think you understand how this is supposed to work, but remember - we want fuzzy roots.

First - this wont work well at all unless you are using an accumulator tank. Second, you must always have MORE pressure built up in the accumulator tank than what the nozzles are running at. Thats why you use a pressure reducer. The pump pressure settings are supposed to make sure two things happen. The tank always has that higher pressure and it keeps the pump from cycling so often.



This is absolutely not true.

The pressure reducer is there for only one reason - to keep the nozzle pressure as CONSTANT as possible. Thats because pressure variations make a HUGE difference in the quality of the mist. Droplet size is directly related to the pressure. Its the pressure and only the pressure that determines droplet size for any given nozzle. Lower pressures = larger droplets.

If your goal is to get fuzzy roots, then you need to control the nozzle pressure as precisely as possible. Allowing the nozzle pressure to vary from 80 to 100 PSI means you will be making a very wide range of droplets. The largest ones will be wasted nutes and will inhibit fuzzy hairs from growing. The smallest may be too small to do the job properly. Very small droplets - 5 microns and smaller - are considered "dry" and dont transfer enough water to keep roots healthy.

This is also why you want ADV's (anti-drip valves) on the nozzles if possible, and a separate solenoid for each nozzle, and keep it as close to the nozzle as possible.

All of these things work together to help you have control over the droplet size and the resulting mist quality.

Again, you might not care about mist quality or droplet sizes or hang time, but remember - we want fuzzy roots. To get fuzzy roots you need correctly sized droplets in a mist that hangs around for a minimum of 1 minute and preferably longer.

There is nothing wrong with smooth roots, but fuzzy roots are a step up.

Every single detail I have been talking about is directed towards that single goal of creating a mist environment that will allow fuzzy roots to grow. Fuzzy roots are the cats meow :)



For a smallish to medium grow - say up to 30 or 40 nozzles with a flow rate of aprox 1 GPH each, the tubing size doesnt matter as far as function. You will not see any significant pressure drops that effect the nozzle performance. Even if you had a large grow with 40 nozzles, you could just increase the pressure reducer setting slightly to off set any slight drop. The flow rate is too low for it to be a serious factor. 1/4" will work just as well as 3/8".

The difference will be felt in your wallet though if you dont try to keep all the components with the same size fittings. Reducers and adapters can easily end up costing more than all the rest of your plumbing combined. If your pump is 1/4", then try to get solenoids, nozzles, valves, filters, regulators, gauges, etc etc all with 1/4". Other than that, it doesnt matter either way.
Ya definitely don't need 3/8" then I'm not a big outfit it's just me myself and I trickiting in my basement
So now that I seen your root chamber my setup that I wanted to make wouldn't work ! I was really looking to try and do sea of green with lots of smaller plants like 1 plant for ever SQ inch in a 4x4 setup thought I could fit 20 in total but now I'm thinking that's way to many. If those roots in your 55 gal is just 1 plant OMG so I'm not not sure what to do ! I been reading lots of your older posts explaining exactly what the root zone should have to be a true aero and if they start touching the tote walls that's not good I didn't know all this ! The cloner I put together isn't an issue I know I loaded it with net cups but I don't have to use all of them at once ! Basically it's really hard trying to get a good design with out test runs I don't like the idea of the bucket set up one plant per bucket I want to use the same tote I have for the cloner but maybe with 5 plants or 4 IDK it's hard making a decision any thoughts
 

Rdubz

Well-Known Member
Just wanted to update finally doing a test run from seed I germinated the seed , dropped in cup of water for 1 day then left it in papper towel for 5 days once I seen the leaf on it , I cut a neoprene collar on half put seedling in it and dropped into 2" net cup and put in cloner. It's been exactly 24hours now and roots are starting to poke under net cup oh also I should mention I'm only using RO at this point. I Will be adding 100 ppm today more like right after I post this ,I'm running the AN jungle juice for now .

Ambient temps 74f
Root temp 69-72f trying to get it to climb a little warmer

Also want to thank @Larry3215 and @waistei for all the help here and i know I still have so much to learn this is only the top of the iceberg!
 

Attachments

Larry3215

Well-Known Member
How much room you need for each plant depends to some degree on the length of the grow. That pic with the super full chamber from a single plant was a C99 mostly sativa plant that I let veg for a loooong time. Total grow time was something like 5 months.

Im now only growing autos with a max of about 3 months from seed to harvest, and the chamber doesnt get nearly that full. Still, I dont think its a good idea to crowd the roots. You cant help but get areas that get too little mist and the nozzles will get over grown that much sooner.

I have three autos in the chamber now with two nozzles, and I ve already had to reach in twice and clear roots away from one of th enozzles because it keeps getting blocked by roots from one plant that sits just a little too close.

Be sure that Jungle Juice doesnt have any organic components. I had horrible luck with AN PH perfect.

That baby looks happy to me :)
 

Rdubz

Well-Known Member
How much room you need for each plant depends to some degree on the length of the grow. That pic with the super full chamber from a single plant was a C99 mostly sativa plant that I let veg for a loooong time. Total grow time was something like 5 months.

Im now only growing autos with a max of about 3 months from seed to harvest, and the chamber doesnt get nearly that full. Still, I dont think its a good idea to crowd the roots. You cant help but get areas that get too little mist and the nozzles will get over grown that much sooner.

I have three autos in the chamber now with two nozzles, and I ve already had to reach in twice and clear roots away from one of th enozzles because it keeps getting blocked by roots from one plant that sits just a little too close.

Be sure that Jungle Juice doesnt have any organic components. I had horrible luck with AN PH perfect.

That baby looks happy to me :)
Thanks man so couple design flaws on my part imo. First of all the way I have it drain still has maybe 1 " of water before it can roll into the balkhead I can't think of anyother way unless I just drill few wholes in the bottom and then let that drain into a sip tray same concept how @Wastei has the 2 bucket setup same concept it can be pumped out bottom tray and then on the other hand that brings me to another thing I was noticing when I opened the lid to look at the roots it felt stagnant too humid if there is a such thing but it felt like it should be aired out if u know what I mean .... So that brings me back to what you told me from the start I should make the chamber out of breathable meterial, ya I think that's the way to go , so now I am trying to still possible use the plastic tote but some how vent it with the fabric from the fabric pots Idk if it would even work I'm trying to wrap my head around what a breathable chamber looks like can I build it with PVC frame and wrap it with fabric but then how do I build foam around it ? I read some of older post and I think u said to build walls around the outside and fabric liner on the inside but I guess I can't visualize it in my head I don't know how u make the gap there! Anyway this has been a awesome learning experience and I can't wait to be able to give my brother some of the best medicine he can get he deals with rheumatoid arthritis it helps his inflammation so much better than any doctor can give it's amazing the power of the plant lol

edit : forgot to mention I played around with the regulator I purchased and you can’t dial the out put past 65 psi at the nozzle sucks that they don’t give u that little detail before u purchase and wait 3 weeks buts it’s ok I’m still using it I like that stopped the squirt after it’s shuts off gives more uniformity in the entire system there’s no more fluctuations in pressure to me that is actually a good add on just need to look for a better Regulator they are hard to find and the ones I do find are like 50-60$, just gotta keep looking but for now I’m going to go with it and see where it takes me I know droplet size is bigger but it’s that or I have it going from 110-85psi maybe I should just let it idk anyway I’m going to run with it for now until it’s replaced
 
Last edited:
Top