Should the US shed blood for Ukraine

Should the USA along with NATO defend Ukraine with troops.

  • Yes

    Votes: 40 40.4%
  • No

    Votes: 59 59.6%

  • Total voters
    99

DIY-HP-LED

Well-Known Member
it's definitely not about oil, or trade at all, really
https://elements.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-ukraines-top-trading-partners-and-products/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=visualizing-ukraines-top-trading-partners-and-products

https://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/balance/c4623.html

we don't do much business with them, and most of that is for raw iron and machinery...

they are strategically placed, but that's of very little benefit to the U.S., NATO has bases nearly as close, already in operation.
as i can see it, the only benefit to us at all is putin shooting himself in the foot...a few times now, the invasion itself, lying to his own troops, badly underestimating the Ukrainians resolve, underestimating the strength of the sanctions that would be brought against him, the world wide abhorrence of his actions...he is destabilizing his own fascist regime.
we literally have to do nothing, and the mad man will kill himself on his own, the only question at this point is how many he takes with him...
After ww2 there were several things done to prevent wars between nation states including the UN another thing was free trade and a global economic system that encouraged trade, trade is good and makes everybody richer. Growing business ties and economic dependency prevent war and that was the idea of an integrated global community of nations with some rules or guides and lot's of international financial institutions to insure stability. China and America are mutually dependent for many things and this tends to prevent conflict, we all like our smartphones and China needs Taiwanese Chips to make things work, so does Russia.

Vlad is suffering the consequences of violating those international rules with catastrophic results for the Russian economy. Because of the nature of communism, they were not really part of the western, now global economic world until recently. So their international dependency is not as great as most countries and they have many internal resources. However being cut off from the world economically and technologically will have dire effects on the Russian economy and on Russians themselves. Even if Vlad ate a bullet in a month, the damage has been done and their money will never be returned, what is frozen will be seized and used as compensation for rebuilding Ukraine and to compensate Ukrainian refugees and victims when this shit is over. Vlad fucked mother Russia more than any enemy pillaging the land could and for that he will probably die at the hands of his own people.
 

DIY-HP-LED

Well-Known Member
https://www.forbes.com/sites/craighooper/2021/12/28/a-ukraine-invasion-will-go-nuclear-15-reactors-are-in-the-war-zone/?sh=49f64daa27aa

the prevailing winds are to the west...major leakage in Ukraine would cover most if not all of the EU, and quit possibly a large swath of the eastern U.S. and Canada, possibly central and south America
Winds usually go from west to east and I'm sure they shift around a lot so that everybody will get a good dose including Russia which is their closest neighbor and not that far from the border. They know all about nuclear power plant disasters in that part of the world and Russia would get hit too.
 

DIY-HP-LED

Well-Known Member
https://www.forbes.com/sites/craighooper/2021/12/28/a-ukraine-invasion-will-go-nuclear-15-reactors-are-in-the-war-zone/?sh=49f64daa27aa

the prevailing winds are to the west...major leakage in Ukraine would cover most if not all of the EU, and quit possibly a large swath of the eastern U.S. and Canada, possibly central and south America
The predominant average hourly wind direction in Zaporizhia varies throughout the year. The wind is most often from the east for 4.4 months, from January 28 to June 9 and for 3.4 months, from September 3 to December 16, with a peak percentage of 35% on March 22. The wind is most often from the north for 2.8 months, from June 9 to September 3, with a peak percentage of 39% on August 5. The wind is most often from the west for 1.4 months, from December 16 to January 28, with a peak percentage of 29% on January 1.
Zaporizhia Climate, Weather By Month, Average Temperature ...
1646369244862.png
 

Fogdog

Well-Known Member
If anybody is on twitter, there is a tweet from

Jennifer Granholm, US energy secretary, said she had activated her agency’s nuclear incident response team and reiterated that no elevated radiation readings had been detected. “The plant’s reactors are protected by robust containment structures and reactors are being safely shut down,” Granholm said on Twitter.

This from Financial Times, paywall so no link provided.
 

DIY-HP-LED

Well-Known Member
If anybody is on twitter, there is a tweet from

Jennifer Granholm, US energy secretary, said she had activated her agency’s nuclear incident response team and reiterated that no elevated radiation readings had been detected. “The plant’s reactors are protected by robust containment structures and reactors are being safely shut down,” Granholm said on Twitter.

This from Financial Times, paywall so no link provided.
From the weather data, the Russians would be poisoning themselves, the wind from the north would drop fallout all over their troops and Crimea. Also any serious incident would mean Russia would get it too, so I figure someone was told to get a fucking brain and back off the attack. It's loss of cooling that is the biggest hazard not so much a breech of containment, but if a core melts down there will be a breech of containment. If they lose grid power and the diesel back ups are destroyed.
 

Roger A. Shrubber

Well-Known Member
Winds usually go from west to east and I'm sure they shift around a lot so that everybody will get a good dose including Russia which is their closest neighbor and not that far from the border. They know all about nuclear power plant disasters in that part of the world and Russia would get hit too.
actually looks like the wind is mostly to the south, at least this time of year...and i shouldn't believe the little blurbs that show up on search pages, apparently...https://windy.app/forecast2/spot/100052/Kiev+Ukraine/map

so then it would shit all over norther africa, turkey, romania
 

Budzbuddha

Well-Known Member
I would think journalists would be a bit more informed about any nuclear plant facility , but most wonder if they can withstand direct military attack.

They were never designed for it . Steel, concrete and lead are designed for scattering and absorption of atomic reactions , not rockets and bombs.

They were designed to encapsulate the reaction chamber / core , cooling , fuel rods , steam generators , pumps and turbines. So, it doesn’t take much to cripple the safety / backup systems if under bombardment. Destroy the structure or the controls that monitor the nuclear reactions , you risk those systems being damaged beyond use . Superheated mass will melt downward as with the corium “ elephants foot “ at Chernobyl.

Destroy its cooling capability and core mass / fuel will superheat and go into meltdown.
 

Sativied

Well-Known Member
Not to be all 'hindsight is 20/20', but this is pretty much the same timeline as the Russian propaganda attack on our nation and rise of the hate mongers here too.

How do we not question that this is just another long term Russian troll?
And same timeline as referendum in NL about a EU association agreement with Ukraine, where Russia faked a video with fake Ukrainian nazis threatening with terrorist attacks in NL if we were to vote against (which the population did anyway for entirely different reasons, which our goverment mostly ignored, a clause was added and they voted yes instead of veto).

As I mentioned earlier in this thread, the reason this particular propaganda is effective is because there is some truth in it. They do have nazi militias, of which some expressed the desire for the type of country the US would want to attack, they did attack lgbt protests, crazy ukrainians attacking gay bars is a thing (majority considers homosexuality as not acceptable), they are quite racist and xenophobic. Making monkey sounds in stadiums towards black players, beating up tourist poc. In 2012 in Lviv 10% of the votes went to an ultraright fascist party (Svoboda). Authorities are known to look away. So why do I not question this is just Russian propaganda? For similar reason we don’t question Mexico has a problem with drug cartels. Way too many people, including Ukrainians who moved west, media and politicians would have to be lying. As Fogdog said a few days ago, it’s not Denmark. It sure ain’t.

Basically despite their good looks they are a little backward in east europe. Not as in retarded, but travelling east means in some ways travelling back in time. That applies to anything from haircuts to views on jews, lgbt, colored people. The more rural areas are worst, as is the case in western countries.

I do not know how the country changed since they voted for Zelensky. Ukraine wasn’t a concern of mine for 6 years and I would have liked to keep it that way. But if most of them were nazis, they wouldn’t have voted for a jewish guy. The conclusion of this article sums it up nicely: “The far right is a problem in Ukraine, but the country is far from a Nazi state.”

It’s actually worse in some neighboring countries east and west from Ukraine…

Obviously in no way a valid excuse for Putin to invade Ukraine and kill innocent people and children. He may just succeed with some denazification though, because however this war ends, the “normal” majority of Ukrainians and authorities will likely be less tolerant towards what Putin labelled them during the war. War changes people. Any Ukrainian nazis left after the war may have to flee to Argentina.
 

DIY-HP-LED

Well-Known Member
Guessing if and when Trumpy has to go get an orange jumpsuit - his escape to Vlad’s Pee Room might have gotten harder as of late.

View attachment 5095865
I think bolting to Russia is not in the cards, Donald said something nasty about Vlad and Vlad operates like Donald. Donald is going to prison and Vlad is going to Hell after eating a bullet. If even Trump fucked the American economy like Putin tanked the Russian economy, you'd burn him at the stake FFS! Besides there are no planes flying to Russia from America, even private ones.
 

zeddd

Well-Known Member
When there is dust rising in a high column, it is the sign of chariots advancing; when the dust is low, but spread over a wide area, it betokens the approach of infantry. When it branches out in different directions, it shows that parties have been sent to collect firewood. A few clouds of dust moving to and fro signify that the army is encamping.

(snicker)
When it’s shaped like a big mushroom it means Putin has hit the red button
 

ANC

Well-Known Member
It just struck me, whether he wins or loses, we all lost.
Just the fact that some people are willing to support someone who instructed the military to attack a country, turn1 million people into refugees, their jobs, houses, careers, deleted because one man decided, fuck them, means we lost as a species.
 

Horselover fat

Well-Known Member
And same timeline as referendum in NL about a EU association agreement with Ukraine, where Russia faked a video with fake Ukrainian nazis threatening with terrorist attacks in NL if we were to vote against (which the population did anyway for entirely different reasons, which our goverment mostly ignored, a clause was added and they voted yes instead of veto).

As I mentioned earlier in this thread, the reason this particular propaganda is effective is because there is some truth in it. They do have nazi militias, of which some expressed the desire for the type of country the US would want to attack, they did attack lgbt protests, crazy ukrainians attacking gay bars is a thing (majority considers homosexuality as not acceptable), they are quite racist and xenophobic. Making monkey sounds in stadiums towards black players, beating up tourist poc. In 2012 in Lviv 10% of the votes went to an ultraright fascist party (Svoboda). Authorities are known to look away. So why do I not question this is just Russian propaganda? For similar reason we don’t question Mexico has a problem with drug cartels. Way too many people, including Ukrainians who moved west, media and politicians would have to be lying. As Fogdog said a few days ago, it’s not Denmark. It sure ain’t.

Basically despite their good looks they are a little backward in east europe. Not as in retarded, but travelling east means in some ways travelling back in time. That applies to anything from haircuts to views on jews, lgbt, colored people. The more rural areas are worst, as is the case in western countries.

I do not know how the country changed since they voted for Zelensky. Ukraine wasn’t a concern of mine for 6 years and I would have liked to keep it that way. But if most of them were nazis, they wouldn’t have voted for a jewish guy. The conclusion of this article sums it up nicely: “The far right is a problem in Ukraine, but the country is far from a Nazi state.”

It’s actually worse in some neighboring countries east and west from Ukraine…

Obviously in no way a valid excuse for Putin to invade Ukraine and kill innocent people and children. He may just succeed with some denazification though, because however this war ends, the “normal” majority of Ukrainians and authorities will likely be less tolerant towards what Putin labelled them during the war. War changes people. Any Ukrainian nazis left after the war may have to flee to Argentina.
Ha, perhaps russia should denazi russia first.
 

Jimdamick

Well-Known Member
In my opinion Putin's 40 mile long convoy is moving very slow if at all.

Biden said Putin is hoping NATO will get involved and Putin will have the War he wants.

We have got to not fall for it.

So NO we must not shed blood in Ukraine and give Putin the War he wants.
Your right, a physical war would play to his advantage
Simply starve his people for a year or two and I doubt he will survive.
 
Top