no, but it is unrealistic.
people are selfish assholes.
Thank you for not trying to deny the simple truth of the bulk of my previous post.
If people are selfish assholes isn't it time individuals started BEING what THEY believe is right and stopped being "selfish assholes" by insisting others comply with their wishes to join them or they will use force against them?
Selfish people do not honor the nonaggression principle. Our highest obligation to others is to leave them alone, if that is their wish. If you feel strongly about doing something "good", do it. Just don't take something from one person and "give" it to another. You have every right to reallocate YOUR resources, but NO right to reallocate anothers without their consent.
To declare willful charity unrealistic is to deny personal responsibility and leads to shifting YOUR wishes into DEMANDS upon others.
Charity is ALWAYS willful or it ceases to be charity. Mass extortion by government and relabeling it "charity" is wordsmithing and THAT is unrealistic.
I endorse charity, I do not endorse extortion.
This "selfish asshole" is heading out now, to help an elder friend get some work done, probably going to buy him a meal too...guess what nobody is making me do it either. See? Simple? Just do it or don't, it's YOUR choice. Who is stopping you?