I'm in total agreement with your post. The major obstacle many growers posting in this organic forum seem to hit is a lack of knowledge about what transpires in a properly prepared grow medium. They seem be mired in a mental state of the entire growing process being dependent on what's added to the grow medium after plants are underway, and the fancier the label, the more aggressive the marketing and the higher the price is the better the end product.USE NEITHER... Any liquid fert will kill all the microbeasties living in your soil on contact. It's all about the micro life in your soil. Use a good organic mix and add some Mayan Microzyme along with a carb. That is all... A healthy population of micro life in your soil makes all the nutes already in the soil available. Make your soil a "Living Ecosystem". You will be over dependant on nutes and pH the second you start adding anything with synthetic salts in them like FoxFarms nutes. This will only open the door to other problems like nuking them, pH or deficiences. Just because it says "organic" on the bottle does not mean that it is.
I no longer use anything offered unless its from a grower I personally know who also grows organic. I don't need that harsh chemical based shit grown in dead soil. Might as well use full on hydro that offers no illusion about being anything but chemicals.