Light Overkill?

Harrekin

Well-Known Member
Is having a 600w HPS in a 80cm x 80cm x 160cm tent for 5 plants overkill? I can control the temps around 25C (77F), but am I going overboard? Just wondering!
 

ontariogrower

Well-Known Member
most likey yes a 600 is good for a 4x4 room what you can do is useing a smaller bulb but turn it sideways alot of people have there bulbs vertical and loose a lots of light
 

Harrekin

Well-Known Member
So if I could control temps, what would be the max amount of light to throw in there before I hit diminishing returns? I have the 600w about 12-16 inches from most of the canopy with no burning, is that ok or too close/far?
 

kevin murphy

New Member
looks sound to me pal... 12-16 inch right lad..just chopped the first one of mine today auto demios it came out better than i thought lol..page 272 pal..keep up the good work lad get some pics on ..
 

BeaverHuntr

Well-Known Member
No such thing as too much light as light = food for the plant. As long as temperature isnt a issue and you are cooling your lights then rock on !! I use a 1000W HPS in my 10' x 10' x 8' high grow room.
 

DrtyBngWtr

Active Member
No such thing as too much light as light = food for the plant. As long as temperature isnt a issue and you are cooling your lights then rock on !! I use a 1000W HPS in my 10' x 10' x 8' high grow room.
So your using at least half the light you should be using.
 

BeaverHuntr

Well-Known Member
So your using at least half the light you should be using.
I didnt say my 10' x 10' room was filled with plants. I have about 6 plants under the light. Its probably a pod thats about 5' x 2' wide.

I dont know if I understood your question..
 

queenster

Active Member
im using 2 1000 watt lights and a 600 watt in a 6 x 10 room and keep my room right at 81 deg. far. and never have a prob. and i got friends that use 6 1000 watts in a 10 x 10 room and love it. and if your using 1 1000 watt in a 10x10 room weather it is full or not your still losing light to room size and not getting the most out of your room either.
 

Harrekin

Well-Known Member
So I could even cram a 1000w in there and as long as temps isnt an issue its not too much light?
 

MJH54321

Well-Known Member
They didnt at all, Iv seen most of them. Im asking whats the most light I can use in a small space before reaching diminishing returns. Doesnt the plant have a light saturation point?
I dont know why your so bothered about it, if your plant looks ok, your temps are fine and your not bothered about electric bills then just use the 600watt, save you having to go spending more money and a smaller bulb and ballast.
 

mrmadcow

Well-Known Member
T.... Im asking whats the most light I can use in a small space before reaching diminishing returns. ...
old rule of thumb is 50-100 watts per square foot. many will argue this & I have done ok w/ only 33 watts per sq b4. adding light over 100 watts per sq ft will still help the plants but your return on your investment drops off. ie; jumping from 50 watts to 80 will increase your yeild by say 20% but jumping from 100 to 130 will only increase your yeild about 7%.
just guessing on percentages to give you an idea what I mean.
as for light saturation,extreme light 3-400 watts per sq will start to bleach the plants.
and someone could jump in and argue that watts per sq foot is an inaccurate way to measure light. lumens are better but when talking about HPS or MH,(& assuming the lights are proper height) watts per sq ft give you a good ballpark idea & are close enough for all but the most anal retentive. ;)
 

Harrekin

Well-Known Member
old rule of thumb is 50-100 watts per square foot. many will argue this & I have done ok w/ only 33 watts per sq b4. adding light over 100 watts per sq ft will still help the plants but your return on your investment drops off. ie; jumping from 50 watts to 80 will increase your yeild by say 20% but jumping from 100 to 130 will only increase your yeild about 7%.
just guessing on percentages to give you an idea what I mean.
as for light saturation,extreme light 3-400 watts per sq will start to bleach the plants.
and someone could jump in and argue that watts per sq foot is an inaccurate way to measure light. lumens are better but when talking about HPS or MH,(& assuming the lights are proper height) watts per sq ft give you a good ballpark idea & are close enough for all but the most anal retentive. ;)
Thanks for that man,specificially about the diminishing returns.
 
Top