How to tell if a picture is fake or photoshopped?

[ScoobyDoobyDoo]

can anyone tell if a picture is fake or has been photoshopped here on the forum? check out these pics and let me know.

https://www.rollitup.org/grow-journals/533449-picture-journal.html

 

[KushXOJ]

Yes those pics were photoshoped

 

[ScoobyDoobyDoo]

Yes those pics were photoshoped

hey kush, how can you tell?

 

[KushXOJ]

Yes those pics were photoshoped

http://www.pskiller.com/

I ran one of my pictures and it said it wasn't photoshoped.

Ran his and it said the picture was manipulated.

 

[ganjames]

they look like professional photographs you would see in a magazine, and with professional photography the pictures are usually edited in photoshop.

 

[ScoobyDoobyDoo]

i mean i run my pics through photoshop just to crop them. they just look like the pice of paper has been inserted with software. it looks too clean and the edges just ren't right. plus the shadows that have been layed across the paper looks funny.

 

[VLRD.Kush]

that PSKiller site is pretty legit dude.

 

[VLRD.Kush]

I second the shadows, and the color of the paper doesn't look the same as the color of the plant and everything else in the room.

I'm a graphic design major *did three and half years and dropped out though*, so I can be somewhat source-able

 

[ganjames]

photoshop get's a pretty bad rap though with people who aren't familiar with it. most people think photoshop and they think of people editing out their fat, covering acne, making there eyes look better (which does happen). but it's a still a great professional tool that photographers (and other people that work in a creative industry) use to make their images more appealing. so it's not a bad thing.

 

[Dr. Greenhorn]

http://www.pskiller.com/

I ran one of my pictures and it said it wasn't photoshoped.

Ran his and it said the picture was manipulated.

thanks for that link!

 

[DSB65]

can anyone tell if a picture is fake or has been photoshopped here on the forum? check out these pics and let me know.

https://www.rollitup.org/grow-journals/533449-picture-journal.html

so your trying to call him out with the pics he posted....

 

[ScoobyDoobyDoo]

photoshop get's a pretty bad rap though with people who aren't familiar with it. most people think photoshop and they think of people editing out their fat, covering acne, making there eyes look better (which does happen). but it's a still a great professional tool that photographers (and other people that work in a creative industry) use to make their images more appealing. so it's not a bad thing.

Yea, I'm not trying to give it a bad wrap. I know it has many useful purposes. Just wanted to know about those specific pics.

 

[ScoobyDoobyDoo]

so your trying to call him out with the pics he posted....

Hell yea...it's pouring rain here and I'm bored.

 

[RyanTheRhino]

Why you gonna start drama over this?

 

[SenorBrownWater]

homebrewer is hella legit.....
i have learned lots off him....
he also takes great pics....
go read this threads .....

 

[RyanTheRhino]

i mean i run my pics through photoshop just to crop them. they just look like the pice of paper has been inserted with software. it looks too clean and the edges just ren't right. plus the shadows that have been layed across the paper looks funny.

I don't know man the shadows in the pictures are on point. would take a master editor

 

[VLRD.Kush]

I don't know man the shadows in the pictures are on point. would take a master editor

not a master. photoshop has so many "one click" features to match up colors and such. And I know most of them aren't really one click, you know what I mean.

 

[KushXOJ]

I'm not saying the plants aren't his I'm just saying those pics have been ran thru PhotoShop and edited.

 

[RyanTheRhino]

Im saying that person would have taken a class or has way to much free time. can you select where the light source is in photo?

 

[ganjames]

not a master. photoshop has so many "one click" features to match up colors and such. And I know most of them aren't really one click, you know what I mean.

psssst, i think it was sarcasm lol.

edit: maybe not.