A couple HVAC questions

nickwin

Well-Known Member
I'm planning the ventilation for my 3x3 or 4x4 grow tent. I am going to use a 6" inline fan to scrub the air, cool a 600w light and exhaust the room (through a window outside), and rely on passive intakes.

I am a little concerned with noise so I have an idea I would like to run by you guys. I am going to use flexible ducting inside the tent, but instead of using flex ducting to go from the tent to the window (only 2-3feet) I am thinking about using a piece of 6" solid metal ducting lined with 1/2" acoustic foam. It would basically be a duct muffler, but it would be the entirety of my out of tent ducting. Is this a good idea? Would it cut back on the noise? Would it restrict air flow to much? If so I was thinking I could use a 8" solid duct with reducers on each end lined with 1" acoustic foam. This would give a full 6" of airflow as apposed to 5" with the first approach.

My second question is regarding the order of ventilation components. Originally My plan was to do it like this: carbon filter-> inline fan-> light-> exit tent and outside. This would put the inline fan in the middle of the chain.

From what I have read, ideally you want the inline fan to be at the end of the chain, pulling air through the system. I could set it up that way: carbon filter-> light-> inline fan-> exit out of tent, but this set up would require an extra 90 degree turn in the flexible ducting. which approach would be better? Or with the extra turn would it be about the same either way? A possible benifit of setting it up the second way is that I could attach the inline fan directly to my DIY muffler/solid duct, and it seems like that might reduce the sound of the inline even more, but I am not sure.
 

Dennis Rodman

Active Member
I think both ways would work.

Here's a suggestion to cut down on noise:
a 6" and 8" inline fan both run off of the same motor, sucking roughly 1 amp. They use the same amount of electricity.
I'd suggest buying an 8" fan (then you're good to go if you ever decide to upgrade) and running it on a speed controller.
A speed controller can help you run at lower RPMs (less noise) and get the same amount of airflow.

Those inline fans are loud as f$%k, but one of these can really quiet them down http://www.afgrowsupply.com/active-air-fan-speed-adjuster/
 

nickwin

Well-Known Member
I think both ways would work.

Here's a suggestion to cut down on noise:
a 6" and 8" inline fan both run off of the same motor, sucking roughly 1 amp. They use the same amount of electricity.
I'd suggest buying an 8" fan (then you're good to go if you ever decide to upgrade) and running it on a speed controller.
A speed controller can help you run at lower RPMs (less noise) and get the same amount of airflow.

Those inline fans are loud as f$%k, but one of these can really quiet them down http://www.afgrowsupply.com/active-air-fan-speed-adjuster/
Is that fan controller universal? I have heard people complaining about getting hum issues when using controllers like that, is that pretty common?
 

Dennis Rodman

Active Member
I've heard of issues with people using dimmer switches as fan speed controllers.
I use this active air one and it works fine. Makes things a lot quieter. I can finally sleep at night!
I've run it with active airs and valuline fans. both were fine
 

nickwin

Well-Known Member
If anyone else has any thoughts on my first post please respond. I am still trying to decide which set up would be better.

thanks

And can anyone give me an estimate of what actual cfm I would get in that set up? I have probably 180 degrees of turns in my ducting all together and a total ducting length of 15-20ft. I am trying to pick out an appropriate carbon filter. The one I am looking at (6x20 Phat filter) recommends a single pass flow of 250cfm.
 
Every 90 degree angle you cut your cfm in half, Add 15-20 ft of duct and a carbon filter and you would be lucky to feel any air movement at all. Great for the smell not so good for climate control. Step up fan and use a fan speed controller. That way you can adjust according to climate/smell demands. A fan speed controller and a dimmer switch are two totally different things. Use a dimmer and you might start a fire/damage fan. A fan speed controller runs about $20
 
Top