derp herp derr, herp derp a hur

B

BigNBushy

Well-Known Member
racerboy71 said:
i'm a little bit lost on this post here.. are you trying to say that all surgeons got better grades in medical school and that's why they're surgeons, and not baby doctors? i had always thought pretty much all doctors have a choice as to what specialty field they decide to go into once they make the cut?
my sister is a nurse, and she always says this.. what do you call a dr who graduated last in his class? dr.. this holds true i'd imagine for surgeons as well as a p.c.p.. just because they're a surgeon it surely doesn't mean they were any smarter then the dr delivering babies, but maybe rather he / she has a better aptitude at being a surgeon ..
Click to expand...
Well, what a doctor becomes is determined by the residency they take.

Your "family doctor" and ER docs were very often the lowest academic performers who graduated in their class.

Surgery (some), radiology and a few other specialties pay significantly more.

Because of that, selection into residency programs to train those fields are significantly more competitive.

So yes, while the old adage "c=md" is true, not all doctors are created equal.

The ER doc made significantly lower grades than the cardiac surgeon in med school.
 
B

BigNBushy

Well-Known Member
abandonconflict said:
Let's not play word games here. This, along with your belief that the vast majority of what are recorded statistically as rape are not, (don't make me keep quoting you) certainly point to what you are getting at. You are dancing as close as you can to saying it with out just stating it bluntly. I'm not mistaken for interpreting it the way I did.

To say you are arguing that makes more sense than to say Strax argued that women do not know rape from consent.
Click to expand...
Me holding that something hinders another thing is totally not the same as me saying it totally prevents it.

As to everything else in your post, I'm not sure how to comment.

You are trying to say I'm saying something, but not telling me what it is you think I'm trying to say.

There are quite a bit of fake rape allegations, and you are bashing me for bringing this up?

A false allegation of rape destroys a man's life much more than an actual rape destroys a woman's.

I would say it is 50/50 on the occurrence of both.
 
S

schuylaar

Well-Known Member
abandonconflict said:
You made quite an absurd statement which was completely different from the thing you accuse him of denying here. Yes, a woman knows the difference between a rape and consent.

However, you are arguing that conception can not occur in the case of rape.

Do you really want to stick with this fallacy? I'll be happy to serve you up some rude logic if so.
Click to expand...
but wait a minute..according to BNB logic, most rapes aren't legit therefore no magic hormone would be released..wouldn't there be more pregnancies?..yet there are not.

:lol:
 
S

schuylaar

Well-Known Member
BigNBushy said:
Well, what a doctor becomes is determined by the residency they take.

Your "family doctor" and ER docs were very often the lowest academic performers who graduated in their class.

Surgery (some), radiology and a few other specialties pay significantly more.

Because of that, selection into residency programs to train those fields are significantly more competitive.

So yes, while the old adage "c=md" is true, not all doctors are created equal.

The ER doc made significantly lower grades than the cardiac surgeon in med school.
Click to expand...
fail. citation required. my doctors went to some of the top medical schools..i wish you could tell them that to their face..but i know, i know..your surgeon sister-in-law (the one who concurs to "special rape hormone") says it's so..so it MUST be..
 
Ceepea

Ceepea

Well-Known Member
BigNBushy said:
Well, what a doctor becomes is determined by the residency they take.

Your "family doctor" and ER docs were very often the lowest academic performers who graduated in their class.

Surgery (some), radiology and a few other specialties pay significantly more.

Because of that, selection into residency programs to train those fields are significantly more competitive.

So yes, while the old adage "c=md" is true, not all doctors are created equal.

The ER doc made significantly lower grades than the cardiac surgeon in med school.
Click to expand...
That's not necessarily true.

Some doctors want to do diagnostics. To blatently make up something like 'ER docs made less grades in med school', is just dumb. You have ZERO information regarding why ER doctors chose to be ER doctors. Maybe some didn't want to do more school, maybe some went to med school to BE A GP.

Your comments are nothing more than baseless assertions that have no footing in reality. Your sample size of one, (your sister) tells us absolutely nothing.

I would rather have the best diagnostician diagnose me than the best surgeon.
 
S

schuylaar

Well-Known Member
BigNBushy said:
Me holding that something hinders another thing is totally not the same as me saying it totally prevents it.

As to everything else in your post, I'm not sure how to comment.

You are trying to say I'm saying something, but not telling me what it is you think I'm trying to say.

There are quite a bit of fake rape allegations, and you are bashing me for bringing this up?

A false allegation of rape destroys a man's life much more than an actual rape destroys a woman's.

I would say it is 50/50 on the occurrence of both.
Click to expand...
spoken like a true academic..
 
Pinworm

Pinworm

Well-Known Member
Ceepea said:
That's not necessarily true.

Some doctors want to do diagnostics. To blatently make up something like 'ER docs made less grades in med school', is just dumb. You have ZERO information regarding why ER doctors chose to be ER doctors. Maybe some didn't want to do more school, maybe some went to med school to BE A GP.

Your comments are nothing more than baseless assertions that have no footing in reality. Your sample size of one, (your sister) tells us absolutely nothing.

I would rather have the best diagnostician diagnose me than the best surgeon.
Click to expand...
reported for academic.
 
S

schuylaar

Well-Known Member
Ceepea said:
That's not necessarily true.

Some doctors want to do diagnostics. To blatently make up something like 'ER docs made less grades in med school', is just dumb. You have ZERO information regarding why ER doctors chose to be ER doctors. Maybe some didn't want to do more school, maybe some went to med school to BE A GP.

Your comments are nothing more than baseless assertions that have no footing in reality. Your sample size of one, (your sister) tells us absolutely nothing.

I would rather have the best diagnostician diagnose me than the best surgeon.
Click to expand...
i know ER doctors and several surgeons as well as those with family or internal medicine practice..the track they took has more to do with what they like and the rush rather than their grades..although grades do play an important part they are not the sole determining factor.
 
Pinworm

Pinworm

Well-Known Member
schuylaar said:
i know ER doctors and several surgeons as well as those with family or internal medicine practice..the track they took has more to do with what they like and the rush rather than their grades..although grades do play an important part they are not the sole determining factor.
Click to expand...
Sky my love. You deserve this heart. <3
 
abandonconflict

abandonconflict

Well-Known Member
BigNBushy said:
Me holding that something hinders another thing is totally not the same as me saying it totally prevents it.

As to everything else in your post, I'm not sure how to comment.

You are trying to say I'm saying something, but not telling me what it is you think I'm trying to say.

There are quite a bit of fake rape allegations, and you are bashing me for bringing this up?

A false allegation of rape destroys a man's life much more than an actual rape destroys a woman's.

I would say it is 50/50 on the occurrence of both.
Click to expand...
You deserve to be bashed, but that is not what I did. I drew a conclusion as to what you were getting at. I took all your arguments in the thread and and explicated your case.

You are arguing that very few if indeed any rapes result in conception.

The two points you are arguing are:

that most accusations of rape are false

that the human female body has natural defense against conception in the case of sexual assault

I'm not asserting your views here, I'm explicating your stupidity. At least stand by what you think. Now that you have argued these premises, conclude.
 
abandonconflict

abandonconflict

Well-Known Member
The thing I give you credit for is that you have nothing. You're playing a shitty hand well. These two cards you're playing are both worthless. Neither one of them can possibly be quantified but you threw in the male victim card and and actually got a couple players to fold. The facts are not in your hand however.

Rape is not over reported, you are aware of this fact.

Rape OFTEN results in conception, you're also aware of this fact.

I also give you credit for knowing better than to continue this hand to its conclusion.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top