Fabric pot vs Air vs Regular

TreeFarmerCharlie

TreeFarmerCharlie

Well-Known Member
xtsho said:
I've found quite a difference in the rigidity of different fabric pots even from the same brand but purchased at different times. Some stand up and stay sturdy while others are made out of a more softer felt like material and are not as rigid. But I don't really move them around. I put them in the flower tent, insert the blumats, and leave them to grow. I also use plastic nursery pots. Usually with soil. They'll all grow weed and I think the pot is a very minor thing with regards to growing. Fabric, plastic, etc... Light and environment are much more important than what type of pot you're growing in.
Click to expand...
They all hold up well once they are filled. Even the stiff ones will soften up after a washing or two.
 
Dontjudgeme

Dontjudgeme

Well-Known Member
xtsho said:
I've found quite a difference in the rigidity of different fabric pots even from the same brand but purchased at different times. Some stand up and stay sturdy while others are made out of a more softer felt like material and are not as rigid. But I don't really move them around. I put them in the flower tent, insert the blumats, and leave them to grow. I also use plastic nursery pots. Usually with soil. They'll all grow weed and I think the pot is a very minor thing with regards to growing. Fabric, plastic, etc... Light and environment are much more important than what type of pot you're growing in.
Click to expand...
I know and understand that now by doing a side by side. I honestly thought the smart pot would grow more vigorously than the regular pot. Gonna try air pots next to come to a solid conclusion.
 
conor c

conor c

Well-Known Member
I like airpots ive got some 15 liter ones but if i wasnt using them id use normal pots tbh
The airpots may not be the cheapest but they are good ime
 
S

spek9

Well-Known Member
Could someone add a brief description of the three pots being discussed here?

I can do my own research, but I'm thinking for future readers it would be handy to provide a description of the differences within the thread itself. I'd do it, but I've only used plastic pots. I've never looked into the other two at all.
 
TreeFarmerCharlie

TreeFarmerCharlie

Well-Known Member
spek9 said:
Could someone add a brief description of the three pots being discussed here?

I can do my own research, but I'm thinking for future readers it would be handy to provide a description of the differences within the thread itself. I'd do it, but I've only used plastic pots. I've never looked into the other two at all.
Click to expand...
Smart Pot (fabric)
81Wg2N9NYgL._AC_SX450_.jpg
Air Pot
French-bean-2-960x600-960x600.jpg

and a "regular" pot, which I'm sure you know what that is.
 
Dontjudgeme

Dontjudgeme

Well-Known Member
To add a little clarification to the previous post, and thank you treefarmer for doing so, the whole idea behind these pots are to provide constant air to the roots so they can breath better by receiving oxygen from all sides of the pot. Supposedly promotes better root growth which in turn should increase plant size. Based on my findings, Im not entirely sure that’s true. Although I won’t be able to tell until harvest, then I can actually see what the roots look like. But based on my side by side, I don’t see any difference in plant growth.
 
jondamon

jondamon

Well-Known Member
Nutty sKunK said:
Air pots are great to transplant with into a final solid plastic pot.

They prune the roots so when transplanted they branch out much swifter than solid pots.

Also I find there growth rate to be quicker as you water more often introducing more nutes/fresh oxygen alongside having more oxygen in the medium.

Watering becomes a hassle and found there’s no real advantage to a final airport. However as mentioned they are superior when it comes to the vegging stage.

Here is an auto before and after transplanting - 7 days growth.

View attachment 4528096
View attachment 4528098
Click to expand...
This was going to be my answer lol.

I used to use airports
spek9 said:
Could someone add a brief description of the three pots being discussed here?

I can do my own research, but I'm thinking for future readers it would be handy to provide a description of the differences within the thread itself. I'd do it, but I've only used plastic pots. I've never looked into the other two at all.
Click to expand...

fabric pots are made of fabric and allow small amounts of air pruning to the roots and I believe a decent flow out of the bottom for drainage.

regular pots are made of moulded plastic and have drain holes in the bottom and allow root circling to happen.

air pots are moulded plastic that come as a flat sheet that you curve around and lock into place. At the bottom is a cage to allow water out of the bottom. And all across the sides are holes in the moulded plastic. Once roots reach those holes air pruning begins on those roots. So you NEVER EVER get any root circling.

I’ve used 2 of the 3. Regular and Air pots.

I now use regular pots. Air pots IME are great for developing a great root structure during veg but I like the roots filling and circling in a regular pot.
 
CBDbear

CBDbear

Active Member
the use I make of fabric pot is having a 1lt fabric to root the clones, if my organization lacks, and it does happen, I can finish whatever I was doing on other side of the room dedicated to flowering
whitout any big issue if short internodes (aren't we all looking forward to that?) and having to add little more fert since they might have finished their "food" stored in the soil. they are expensive that is a true fact!
 
Nutty sKunK

Nutty sKunK

Well-Known Member
jondamon said:
This was going to be my answer lol.

I used to use airports



fabric pots are made of fabric and allow small amounts of air pruning to the roots and I believe a decent flow out of the bottom for drainage.

regular pots are made of moulded plastic and have drain holes in the bottom and allow root circling to happen.

air pots are moulded plastic that come as a flat sheet that you curve around and lock into place. At the bottom is a cage to allow water out of the bottom. And all across the sides are holes in the moulded plastic. Once roots reach those holes air pruning begins on those roots. So you NEVER EVER get any root circling.

I’ve used 2 of the 3. Regular and Air pots.

I now use regular pots. Air pots IME are great for developing a great root structure during veg but I like the roots filling and circling in a regular pot.
Click to expand...
Lol

Guess it’s not too much of an issue if you’re growing photos a can just veg a little longer etc. But transplanting autos it’s a race against time.

They always circle their final pot too.

Plus it’s a huge pain in the ass if they dry out too much. Water just shoots out the sides haha
 
Dontjudgeme

Dontjudgeme

Well-Known Member
Nutty sKunK said:
Lol

Guess it’s not too much of an issue if you’re growing photos a can just veg a little longer etc. But transplanting autos it’s a race against time.

They always circle their final pot too.

Plus it’s a huge pain in the ass if they dry out too much. Water just shoots out the sides haha
Click to expand...
Smart pots do the same thing if the water you put in is placed directly around the edges. With smart pots, I tend to water from the center to the edges. I thought the same thing about the air pots, those holes just seem like they would drain the water quickly, forcing you to water more frequently. At least with the smart pots the soil has to be pretty saturated before you see it sleeping out the sides.
 
FastFreddi

FastFreddi

Well-Known Member
I always rough up the top of my medium with my fingers, make a slight moat around outside edges, and water away..works well if not pouring too much at once. I hand water by bucket and pitcher. Just my method.
FF
 
CBDbear

CBDbear

Active Member
to be fair you might want to have the roots to fill up the pot than judge, my final pot is a plastic one i simply put perlite on the bottom and voilà air pruning but just on a 1/6 of the pot surface.
 
HydroOrganicFla

HydroOrganicFla

Well-Known Member
quirk said:
Optical Delusion
Click to expand...

Appreciate the side-by-side, that's the first one I've seen.

I picked up some of the propagation sized air-pots for seedlings, figure it's an easy container to transplant into final container and will hopefully help the root system get established well.




They are .3gal/1 liter sized so I think they'll be good for starters.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top