The Green Griffin
Well-Known Member
Calling a lot of BS on that paper and MOST of the conclusions presented about 'amino acids' effects on plant physiology.
We had this discussion 10 years ago. Amino Acids mostly feed bene's is the PROVEN conclusion.
The ag industry isn't really jumping on board because it will lower their production, so our slow degradation of soil continues unabated. Monsanto is still pushing the sterile dirt + roundup as an alternative. Most people by now realize its simply poison.
The answer these guys are looking for are staring them in the face. Mychorrizae and bene's. If you are feeding them aminos and you've got some sympathetic myco spores or benes: boom. I'm very disappointed there is no detailed root structure comparisons. And no accountability in monitoring these 'bene' factors.
Can you imagine them mass spraying cytokinins or BAPs on field crops? Anyone have any idea how biologically toxic this stuff is?
Star dust, if you have no controls, you have nothing reportable. Period. No controls: no science.
Long term myco inoculation into crops, done as a matter of crop preparation, usually by growing a very sympathetic plant and establishing the mycelial network throughout the soil is the ideal. Current limitations however have shown that even low grade phosphorous enrichment will destroy the bene's. -Also, depleted soil will require remediation time between crops. <--That's a big reduction of output. So, they're gonna keep burning that soil.
At least the farmers are well aware of this issue. They do detailed soil composition and rather precise NPK dosing. There's still time and hope.
I wish the solution would be hydroponics. But even a brief cost analysis damns that solution. We simply require a lot of good soil to feed humanity.
Agree that without controls there is no proof in this case that the addition of aminos resulted in improved growth. Could be a great pheno, could be better mycor and bene support (which also could be from the aminos) or other factors. Two thing stand out though. We have a highly experienced grower who knows the strain well, is seeing significant growth improvement over what he would expect, and that plant is looking flat out incredible. Certainly good directional info that indicates a full blown test with multiple plants and controls is needed, unless that already exists somewhere - which it probably does. Do you have any links, Masterpiece, that could help us out? Whether the benefit is from direct absorption by the plant or better beneficials support is irrelevant to the casual grower who simply wants to know if it is worth using the aminos, but some of us are trying to understand as many of the dependent variables as possible and HOW they work so I hope we dig deeper. BTW, one plant and one control would be more insightful, but a larger scale would be far more scientifically accurate. Thanks for this thread......some good stuff!