Update:
Alright so i went over to the house and talked to the house owner. It turns out he filed a police report, cuz someone broke into his house and jumped over the fence. Initially i was just trying to see his reaction when i say that i called the cops. He seems legit and apologized over and over so i dont think its him. He did say that it could be one of his son's friends cuz hes a shady bastard. It all fits in with who i thought it was. Thanks for all the advice