This test is to compare the Arctic Alpine 11 ($10) versus the Rosewill RCX-Z1 ($13). The Rosewill received bad reviews, probably due to its lack of capacity (surface area 1525cm²). This means it would perform poorly under large loads of heat. But for our purposes, it has a nice flat copper pad, a thick base plate and thick fins. It has a high RPM so I didnt bother testing it at 9V. In summary, the Rosewill very slightly outperforms the Alpine 11, and that is using the stock paste with no surface prep for both.
I added the Arctic Freezer 7 Pro for a direct comparison.
Tested using CXA3070 AB bin running at 1.45A. Ambient temp was 23C
---------------------------------
Stock Alpine 11 (MX4 paste)
fan 5V - 2.9% temp droop
stable heatsink temp 28.5C
fan .555W
fan 9V - 1.87% temp droop
stable heatsink temp 26C
fan 1.87W
----------------------------------
Stock Rosewill RCX-Z1
fan 5V - 2.11% temp droop
stable heatsink temp 28C
fan .72W
-----------------------------------
Arctic Freezer 7 Pro
fan 9V - 1.33% temp droop
stable heatsink temp (25C fins, 29C copper pad)
fan 1.63W
fan 5V - 2.43% temp droop
stable heatsink temp (28.5C fins, 31C copper pad)
fan .504W
-----------------------------------
Baseline 42%
Alpine 11 @5V - 40.36%
Alpine 11 @9V - 39.8%
Rosewill @5V - 40.56%
Freezer 7 @5V - 40.6%
Freezer 7 @9V - 40.2%