hey
@CobKits, I'm looking for a recommendation for upgrading my almost 3 year old CXA3070 setup... basically I want to reuse my 4 heatsinks and drivers and just change the cobs/holders...
youre in luck 3070s use 35mm holders so you wont have to redrill for citizen clu048 or luminus cxm22. as far as the 61% eff supra quoted it appears that eff. number may have been overstated a bit but we have relative data from cob to cob to work with. Look at the relative performance of these cobs at your target 35-50W:
the two citizen CLU048s (1212 and 181
are gen5 but gen 6 is out now. your 3070s are prob similar to that 1212 gen 5. extrapolating from a separate test the gen 6 1212 run about 5% over gen 5 so gen6 1212 is probably close to the CXB, or a shade below. the gen6 1212 is $13. the next thing id rec is the $17 CXM22 which you see at 20-60W is about efficient as any chip out there including the 72V vero C and the CLU058-1825 (both ~$35). (CLU058-1825 is also in gen 6 so is likely a little above that but at that point youre redrilling your heatsinks so id keep it simple
so 1212, 1818, and CXM22 all match up to the holes with your current heatsinks
1212 is a 36V chip and will run similar to your 3070s on those drivers. CXM22 and 1818 are 50V chips but are also just about as efficient at 1050mA as the 1212 is, but theyre pushing 50W each. you can get 3 of them on a driver and that will be clsoe to what youre getting now with your 4 3070s per driver (152W). you can also tag a 36V chip on the tail end to max that driver out if you want
also if your heatsinks are bars, replacing 4 36V/36W chips for 3 50V/50W chips should be fine. if you have pinfins jumping from 36 to 50 may leave you needing more cooling
that said dont pitch those 3070s they got a lot of life left in em. you can probably find another use for them theyre still great chips and relatively not that dated. maybe build a super rig at low current, put all 8 of em all on an hlg-150-36B you'll need less heatsinks for that as well as they'll be 20W each.
you need to do the math on whether dropping $100-120 or more on new chips right now is worth the extra 5% efficiency bump. may be best to wait it out another year or more with the 3070s. also depends what bin they are i guess. if you were early on you may be down a bin or two and that would factor into your decision as it could be a 10% performance bump