Is Happy Frog soil any good?

trippy3

Member
Just found out the local store is out of Ocean Forest, any comments on Happy Frog would be appreciated, thank you.
 

trippy3

Member
thank you, other than perlite, should I ad anything else? Also Foxfarm gives the ph of OF but not HF, anyone
know?
 

drolove

Well-Known Member
always add some lime. and happy frog works fine. and on another note FFOF never seemed too hot for seedlings. never had an issue and for a long time thats all i used.
 

T.Huxley

Well-Known Member
Sorry to hijack trippy, but I've been using happy frog for my babies with no added perlite, as I plan on transplanting to FFOF with perlite. They look healthy as ever. Any problems with this?
 

trippy3

Member
Ok, just got the HF and tested it with a cheap sunleaves meter that's not exact but said 6.5, does it need to be higher, I don't understand
why the lime?
 

bmeat

New Member
Sorry to hijack trippy, but I've been using happy frog for my babies with no added perlite, as I plan on transplanting to FFOF with perlite. They look healthy as ever. Any problems with this?
nah you pay a lot for fox farm, it better be good.

i just found a new soil. its 50% peat moss, perlite and lime stone "to help with ph adjustments"

will let you know how it works on my masterkush i will sow this week

peat is nice like coco, but compacts more than coco over time. gotta try and keep it fluffing while roots are going down
 

racerboy71

bud bootlegger
Ok, just got the HF and tested it with a cheap sunleaves meter that's not exact but said 6.5, does it need to be higher, I don't understand
why the lime?
lime buffers ph, btw, i've never checked soil ph in me life and never had an issue..
 

bmeat

New Member
Ok, just got the HF and tested it with a cheap sunleaves meter that's not exact but said 6.5, does it need to be higher, I don't understand
why the lime?
adding nutes lowers ph. they have 5.5 buffers i think. its an attempt to over correct for the over feeding mistakes, they add extra lime stone.

plus its a good mineral for the plant to absorb..so is perlite..any kinda rock really that isnt toxic or radioactive
 

racerboy71

bud bootlegger
adding nutes lowers ph. they have 5.5 buffers i think. its an attempt to over correct for the over feeding mistakes.

plus its a good mineral for the plant to absorb..so is perlite..any kinda rock really that isnt toxic or radioactive
perlite doesn't get absorbed by the plants, it's used simply to make the soil looser and to allow more air to the roots, not as a nutrient to be used by the plants..
 

cannabineer

Ursus marijanus
Ok, just got the HF and tested it with a cheap sunleaves meter that's not exact but said 6.5, does it need to be higher, I don't understand
why the lime?
The lime is insurance against the soil "souring" which it will eventually do, like many peat-based soils. Dolomite lime also confers the benefit of adding magnesium, as ime FFHF is a bit light in that ion for our preferred cultivars. 2/3 cupful of powdered dolomite per bag of HF should do ya, or a tablespoon per gallon.
I've just planted some rooted cuts in last year's Happy Frog (no extra lime), and I will say the soil didn't do well after drying all the way out and being rehydrated. It loses an awful lot of strange black grit when watered now. And it's developed a positive dislike of wetting. My grow last year in fresh HF went wonderfully (although be advised ... about 2 months in it ran out of nutrition all at once, and I supplemented with GH Flora three-part as if running soilless, with good results) but toward the end the soil began beading water and developing cracks/channels which made a thorough watering a bit of a hassle. cn
 

bmeat

New Member
perlite doesn't get absorbed by the plants, it's used simply to make the soil looser and to allow more air to the roots, not as a nutrient to be used by the plants..
its a volcanic gas/rock with some nutrient value. mircale grow throws any kind of random shale in their scotts permium..its not bad soil, just not enough peat.

cant wait to try my new suff :)
 

racerboy71

bud bootlegger
of course it does..its an element lmao its a volcanic stone with some nutrient value. mircale grow throws any kind of random shale in their scotts permium..its not bad soil, just not enough peat.

cant wait to try my new suff :)
would you care to tell me how what is basically a rock gets absorbed by a a plant?? if you've ever looked at any old soil that's been used, you will still see huge chunks of perlite in it.. it's not getting absorbed by the plant, christ, usually i don't get into idiotic debates with you, but jesus, perlite is not used by the plants, people only put it in the soil to add oxygen to the root zone, not as a nutrient..

how about this, next grow, add only perlite to your grow and only water, and get back to me and let me know how well it went..
 

racerboy71

bud bootlegger
sorry for the slight hijack op, i usually don't get sucked into a debate with bmeat, i'm done now... sorry for the interruption ....
 

trippy3

Member
Thank you Cannabineer. Lot of good info. Anything else, worm castings or epsom salt, if so ratio plz. Also what size bag of HF
you referring to. I got the 2 cu/ft. bags.
 

cannabineer

Ursus marijanus
Thank you Cannabineer. Lot of good info. Anything else, worm castings or epsom salt, if so ratio plz.
Worm castings might be nice, but I would not use Epsom salt except as a sort of RedBull energy shot for a plant displaying definite Mg appetite. I'm not a seasoned organic gardener ... I live better through chemistry. ;) cn

<edit> for a slower Mg release I'd consider langbeinite (a less soluble magnesium potassium sulfate). It's sold as Sul-Po-Mag at garden centers (I use Orchard Supply here in the 'Stan) and makes a nice source of three of the plant's most greedily noshed ions ...
 

racerboy71

bud bootlegger
Worm castings might be nice, but I would not use Epsom salt except as a sort of RedBull energy shot for a plant displaying definite Mg appetite. I'm not a seasoned organic gardener ... I live better through chemistry. ;) cn
i've been adding about a cup or so of worm poo to my ffof and they seem to love the added nitrogen.. also great for making teas out of ime as well..
i'm with the bear though, not a real big fan of epsom salts as i've seen them cause more issues then they fix.. if anything, i'll use a bit of cal / mag plus liquid during the grow if they look like they could use a boost..
 

bmeat

New Member
i've been adding about a cup or so of worm poo to my ffof and they seem to love the added nitrogen.. also great for making teas out of ime as well..
i'm with the bear though, not a real big fan of epsom salts as i've seen them cause more issues then they fix.. if anything, i'll use a bit of cal / mag plus liquid during the grow if they look like they could use a boost..
cool, you make teas?

try banana and the shell in a brew for heavy p and k.
 
Top