Yeah, 5.8 is a little low. If your pouring in 6.5 and getting 5.8 on the runoff, that tells you that your soil PH is lower than 5.8, probably close to 5.0. You probably have some nutelock going on, or maybe even just plain underfeeding, hard to say. When you "treated them with lime" did you flush, or did you just give them a heavy watering, mixed with the lime? Whenever I flush for PH problems, I use water PH'ed to 6.8 and keep flushing til my runoff comes out close to that(at least 6.6). Then, I know the PH is okay, rather than hoping it's okay. I usually end up using about 6 gallons for my 3 gallon pots, and it works perfectly. But, the only way to know for sure, is to have your meters handy. I also make sure the runoff PPM is below 150, and flowing almost clear.