Results should be similar, given all the other variables are the same.I was looking at Live Soil and comparing it to Organic Nutes.
I’m asking what has a larger yield?
I currently work in an organic grow facility, I can't share much about what we do(nda), but I believe I can say this. We scratch dry amendments into the surface usually once a week for the whole life of the plant to maintain proper nutrition to the soil web and they get a few different teas. This grows huge plants that we have to heavily trim back several times to maintain a functional canopy to flower. After about 10 weeks of veg and 8-12 weeks of flower they yield some very dank terpy nugs, and usually about 1.8-2 lbs per 1k light.
Previously I spent over 10 years doing Sea of Green style flood and drain hydroponics, in a perpetual cycle. I used 6 inch pots of hydroton in a 4x4 flood tray under a 1k hps. I took clones off small mother plants every 2ish weeks. Then I potted the previous batch of clones and put them into veg, and put the veg plants into flower every 2ish weeks. I also harvested about 25% of my flower room at the same time. I was able to fit 45ish clones into my flower tray at a time, so usually I had cycles of 10-12 plants every 2ish weeks. The plants went into flower about 7-8 inchs tall and finished between 25-30 inchs typically. That garden produced the dankest nugs many people I shared with had ever seen. Smell them across the room while the bag is still in my pocket kind of nugs. Yield depends on genetics obviously but a low average was 20g per plant(20gx45plants=900g dried) or roughly 2lbs per 1k light. My typical average was around 25g per plant or 2.5 lbs per 1k, and my highest yielders would put out over 30g dried per plant.
As of yet I havn't found a grow method that out produces SOG f+d in the same time frame. Obviously you can veg out giant plants that produce huge yields, but that all takes time and space. With SOG you can turn over 2 harvests in the time it usually takes a person to finish one veg/harvest cycle.
I absolutely appreciate well grown and properly fed cannabis. I am a firm believer that you can achieve the exact same level of results whether you use organic methods or whether you use direct mineral feeding through bottled or dry nutrients. The key is using good products either way, giving the plants the balanced nutrition they need, and not going overboard. You can still easily overfeed and ruin plants with organics.
Genetics …. Pee … yes peegrowing experiance,
honestly I'm not a big fan of slow release nutrients. Its one of the things I didn't love about growing outdoors with mostly dry amendments. I have to be think about what the plant MIGHT need in 2 weeks, not what it looks like it needs now. The break down and release of the dry amendments felt really slow, and like I had no real control over what was happening with my plants. In the end I managed them well and they all turned out decent, but the whole time it was annoying to me.ProRelease™
Our Controlled Release Fertilizers (CRF) are granulated fertilizers designed to be applied directly to a plant’s root zone. CRFs slowly and predictably release fertilizer over time, continuously feeding for months with only a single application! This allows for unprecedented ease of use and...generalhydroponics.com
I keep eying the WC mix of that.
The swedes use it alot in there gardening and swear by ithes not kidding about the pee, watered down 10-1 water / pee it can be used most waterings/feedings
Thank you for this well thought out explanation. I appreciate it.honestly I'm not a big fan of slow release nutrients. Its one of the things I didn't love about growing outdoors with mostly dry amendments. I have to be think about what the plant MIGHT need in 2 weeks, not what it looks like it needs now. The break down and release of the dry amendments felt really slow, and like I had no real control over what was happening with my plants. In the end I managed them well and they all turned out decent, but the whole time it was annoying to me.
I'm nervous something like the slow release GH product would really exacerbate that lack of control I felt. I would also be concerned about the nutrient balance getting out of wack as the plants ate certain things and left others behind in the medium. If the "granules" take months to break down it might become unpredictable.
The greenest spot in the lawn is always over the septic tank.hes not kidding about the pee, watered down 10-1 water / pee it can be used most waterings/feedings
No thats not what I meant.I dont mean any offense, but Im not sure if you understand what youre asking.
You *can feed living soil organic nutes.
Some people swear by teas, Clackmas Coot swears theyre pointless.
I would advise listening to @Thundercat if you want weight and watching Build A soils youtube videos about organic growing if you want to grow organic with little to no experience.