What about something like NFTG (semi-organic option right?) then you'd also pick another true salt/chemical line to give you a 3-way compare. I'm sitting on some Botanicare Kind from when I thought I was going hydro but atm I'm on the organics/soil crew. So my next hydro attempt would use what I've got on hand.
Otherwise, Botanicare PureBlend Pro was what I had tried earlier on, and I'd also consider maybe Ionic. I've seen lots of folks comment that PBP wasn't a horrible choice so I'd give it a nod. Whatever new products I look into though, I'm going to bias things towards dry powders rather than shipping water around the country. I've not done my homework on dry options but I have seen lots of people talking about that MegaCrop so it'd make my short-list of options to consider.
So many options to try, I'd start with first identifying what you want out of the nutrient line - i.e. what needs to be in there and how much of each. Then I'd look at those who come the closest with the least # of bottles I've got to buy and at what price points I'm willing to tolerate. And of course looking for something not associated with hydro/weed and from agricultural/farming sources offers great savings from what I've observed in my limited research.
