Phos Def? Everything is within range; need fresh eyes to help

RuggedWombat

Well-Known Member
Indoors
Fox Farms Ocean Forest
2 3 gal smart pots sprouted 3/24 (white widow, Bubba Kush
4 5 gal smart pots sprouted 4/10 (3 Blueberry, 1 Galaxy)
Watering schedule 1 gallon water every 3 days PH 6-6.5 PPM under 700.
Tap water is naturally alkaline at 7.5 or so and PPM around 200.
Nutrient schedule is week 3 veg on the drain to waste table on https://www.growweedeasy.com/general-hydroponics-flora-trio-guide
Flora Trio: 1/2 tsp Micro, 1/2 tsp Gro, 1/4 tsp Bloom. Total PPM is kept under 700.
Lights: HLG 100 R spec x2 at 18 inches from WW and BK
Temps 73-81 F with AC 6 in fan running at 4/8 speed.
All plants topped at 4th node once 6 nodes in height
5/8 Soil Slurry Results:
BK: 335 PPM PH 6.8
WW: 370 PPM PH 6.8
Front Right BB plant: 552 PPM 6.7 PH (I've been feeding PH at 6-6.2 to bring down PH since then)

The leaf cuttings are from the Bubba Kush plant pictured in #2. Pic #3 is the White Widow. Pic #1 shows all of the plants for comparison. The smaller plants are about 2 to 2 and a half weeks behind the BK and WW. Some of the newer plants are starting to show the same tell tale signs of WW and BK. Purpling stems, yellowing between the veins which turns into dead spots, ends of the leaf get crispy, fan leaves sometimes twist sideways, some of the leaves seem papery dry, WW especially seems to have leaf cupping issues despite the lights being pretty far away. All I can think of is nutrient lockout due to PPM in the soil being too high or low. I haven't flushed any of them yet because my last grow made me scared to flush since they suffered from so much chronic overwatering. I do water until they have a bit of runoff, but I've become much more concerned with overwatering. Also of note, the soil medium of the plants isn't "fluffy" like when the plants were smaller, but I attributed that to all the root growth impacting the consistency of the soil. Its also possible that the soil was so hot for the first several weeks that adding nutrients just choked the plants with nutrients. However, you would think that the BK and WW would be balanced out by now considering how far along they are. This is my second grow, and I'm getting better, but holy shit I don't want to start flower when I can't even keep plants green in veg. What information have I left out? I know I'm missing something fundamentally simple since the same thing is happening to all 6 of these plants and happened to the last 3 autos. I don't know how I could even flush all 6 of these bastards (26 gallons of soil). I've been thinking maybe plain water feedings for a week, but I'm of course scared that if the issue IS really lack of nutrients in the soil and not lockout, then they will really be flushing. So many symptoms have comorbidity; how the hell can I ever narrow down definitively?
 

Attachments

Snoopy808

Well-Known Member
Well dont be scared to do something.
There phosphorus deficiency for sure. Is it under fed? Needing co factors like extra cal mag? Under watered, or draining and drying too quickly. Which can harden the soil, and contribute to salt build up which would probably acidify the soil.
The plants dont look too big for the pot. Ie not root bound. What I would do is get a large tote or your tub, fill with water pH it to 6.8-7. Saturate the pots fully, dunk em till they dont float anymore and stop bubbling. Then let drain. That would do 3 things. Condition the soil for a liquid feed. Fully hydrate the plant and soil. Flush/pull anything, a salt, that is in high concentration. Then top dress with dolomite lime. It will give cal mag as well as pH up buffer for acidity. Water it in when the soil is wet. The ions will move and do their thing optimal. ((Or use a calcium and magnesium supplement with pH buffers in it)) Then feed with phosphorus boost with your veg feed.

This will help too
 

RuggedWombat

Well-Known Member
Well dont be scared to do something.
There phosphorus deficiency for sure. Is it under fed? Needing co factors like extra cal mag? Under watered, or draining and drying too quickly. Which can harden the soil, and contribute to salt build up which would probably acidify the soil.
The plants dont look too big for the pot. Ie not root bound. What I would do is get a large tote or your tub, fill with water pH it to 6.8-7. Saturate the pots fully, dunk em till they dont float anymore and stop bubbling. Then let drain. That would do 3 things. Condition the soil for a liquid feed. Fully hydrate the plant and soil. Flush/pull anything, a salt, that is in high concentration. Then top dress with dolomite lime. It will give cal mag as well as pH up buffer for acidity. Water it in when the soil is wet. The ions will move and do their thing optimal. ((Or use a calcium and magnesium supplement with pH buffers in it)) Then feed with phosphorus boost with your veg feed.

This will help too
Thanks for the reply! I hadn't been watering to runoff, so I theorized the salt build up was causing the crust and causing lockout. Lo and behold, I use 2 gallons instead of the normal 1 gallon and I get enough runoff to require the wet vac. 24 hrs later and the leaves were perky and praying. The soil is also noticeably fluffier now. I think my big takeaway lessons so far have been:

1. Overwatering is frequency, not volume
2. Watering to runoff is critical in soil
3. I've never had an actual deficiency that wasn't caused by lockout of one kind or another.
4. I should be growing in coco

Luckily as I control for more and more of the issues, the number of possibilities continues to dwindle. I'm growing 4 different strains and they are all looking gorgeous so far 1 week into flower. I'm sure I'll develop new issues since they are so healthy they are now exploding and fighting each other for space. Even the Bubba Kush in the top left is now a vibrant green again!
 

getogrow

Well-Known Member
Thanks for the reply! I hadn't been watering to runoff, so I theorized the salt build up was causing the crust and causing lockout. Lo and behold, I use 2 gallons instead of the normal 1 gallon and I get enough runoff to require the wet vac. 24 hrs later and the leaves were perky and praying. The soil is also noticeably fluffier now. I think my big takeaway lessons so far have been:

1. Overwatering is frequency, not volume
2. Watering to runoff is critical in soil (until you learn how much to feed each strain)
3. I've never had an actual deficiency that wasn't caused by lockout of one kind or another.
4. I should be growing in coco (bah humbug)

Luckily as I control for more and more of the issues, the number of possibilities continues to dwindle. I'm growing 4 different strains and they are all looking gorgeous so far 1 week into flower. I'm sure I'll develop new issues since they are so healthy they are now exploding and fighting each other for space. Even the Bubba Kush in the top left is now a vibrant green again!
 

Snoopy808

Well-Known Member
Thanks for the reply! I hadn't been watering to runoff, so I theorized the salt build up was causing the crust and causing lockout. Lo and behold, I use 2 gallons instead of the normal 1 gallon and I get enough runoff to require the wet vac. 24 hrs later and the leaves were perky and praying. The soil is also noticeably fluffier now. I think my big takeaway lessons so far have been:

1. Overwatering is frequency, not volume
2. Watering to runoff is critical in soil
3. I've never had an actual deficiency that wasn't caused by lockout of one kind or another.
4. I should be growing in coco

Luckily as I control for more and more of the issues, the number of possibilities continues to dwindle. I'm growing 4 different strains and they are all looking gorgeous so far 1 week into flower. I'm sure I'll develop new issues since they are so healthy they are now exploding and fighting each other for space. Even the Bubba Kush in the top left is now a vibrant green again!
Acidic aerobic soils, with regular prudent irrigation dont dry out well and can also cause visual over watering symptoms too.
Coco....eh...that's another learning curve and conditioning media/ cation saturation issues. FFS there's no coco available right now! Soils arent being made that use coco. Hemp growers are using a huge amount of made soils, leaving us smaller ganja farmers without. Seen the price of dep plastic? $1k increase for a 100 foot roll. If you can get it.
 

maranibbana

Well-Known Member
As someone who has already sank a lot into my grow, what one product would you suggest? The amount of different products is insane and the flora trio is as far as I've gone with adding products to the soil.
I will stand by the rootwise soil dynamics line. It’s expensive. But the results are KILLER. Reach out on IG to them @rootwisesoildynamics.
 

Snoopy808

Well-Known Member
As someone who has already sank a lot into my grow, what one product would you suggest? The amount of different products is insane and the flora trio is as far as I've gone with adding products to the soil.
Any clean compost or worm casts will have all the microbes you need.
 
Top