Recent Hollywood remakes of asian movies: is America losing it's touch??

makaha99

Active Member
So in the last few years, there's been a lot of asian films that were remade by Hollywood. Some examples are The Grudge which was a remake of the Japanese movie Ju-on, The Ring which was a remake of the japanese film Ringu, The Lake House with Sandra Bullock and Keanu Reeves which was a remake of the South Korean film Il Mare. The Martin Scorsese crime thriller The Departed which won an Academy Award for Best Picture was a remake of the Hong Kong film Infernal Affairs (which was a better movie). The Hunger Games was pretty much a ripoff of Battle Royale, a japanese fiilm/novel that came out over ten years earlier.

Like most people, I used to love Hollywood movies, but it seems story/plot wise Hollywood has gotten stale in recent years. Special effects in Hollywood continue to be absolutely amazing and groundbreaking, but I find a lack of substance underneath it.

While Hollywood has been decling, asian films and also asian director's prestige has increased. Arguably, the two best director's on the planet are from asia--Park Chan-wook from South Korea, and Wong Kar-wai from Hong Kong. Wong Kar-wai is such a fantastic director that Jude Law, David Strathairn, Natalie Portman and Rachel Weisz all jumped at the chance to work with him in the film My Blueberry Nights.

Yes this does go back earlier, not just to the influence of Bruce Lee on world cinema, but going back further, to japanese director Akira Kurosawa, considered by many as one of the best directors of all time. Steven Speilberg, George Lucas, Francis Ford Coppola (The Godfather), and Martin Scorsese all worshipped the ground Kurosawa walked on. Steven Speilberg was quoted as saying "I have learned more from him than from almost any other filmmaker on the face of the earth" George Lucas has gone on record saying that Kurosawa's Hidden Fortress was his inspiration for Star Wars. George Lucas and Francis Ford Coppola were the catalysts behind getting 20th Centruy Fox to finance Kurosawa's Kagemusha. So asian influence on world cinema is not new, but it seems recently, especially regarding South Korean films, asian films are on the rise.

So my question is, can Hollywood regain it's edge?
 

sunni

Administrator
Staff member
i dont see it as an issue, honestly there are films adapted from western that are made into asian movies for everyone to watch not everyone enjoys reading subtitles, not everyone wants to hear horrible dubs, so is it really abig issue to remake it? Why not share the story with everyone no matter what language I think that is would be really awesome to hear your movie from japan has been remade in america or vice versa
 

Rancho Cucamonga

Active Member
I like some of the Asian films. The Host, Battle Royale, I saw the Devil, Audition was over-rated but had some good scenes, Suicide Club, and on and on. I actually enjoyed the remakes, the ring, the grudge, shutter ect. There really is no good horror anymore so the mediocre tends to pass as good enough being there is nothing there.
The Departed was one of the best films from now until then, not many ones like that come around often even if it is a sketchy remake of some Asian blockbuster I found to be average.
Then there is films like Crouching tiger, Hero, Oldboy, Fireworks and others that are considered the top Asian movies of all-time that i find fairly average.
Compare those to gems like Godfather, Shawshank, Goodfellas, the Star Wars series, Seven, Silence of the lambs, Carlitos Way, American History X, Apocalypse Now, Terminator series, Alien and on and on. They just don't compare. And that may be just because of the language barrier or whatever, but compare American movies over the last 20 and then compare Asian over the last 20 and it's not even a contest.
I will say Asian films may be on a uprun of late because of the failed American movie industry of late. As for will American movies come back I really can't say. I think the industry has run out of remakes, sequels and most importantly good writers.
If there is some good talent and movies ready to come out of the Asian movie market we will see it now because the American industry is currently fucked. There were some gems out there in 2012 like Marley, The Loved Ones, The Master, The dark knight rises(HELL NO, I hate comic book films) but a few others like Django(kidding that sucked to) I think Tarantino's fall is a good vision of what's happened to hollywood in general, bad writing. The cabin the woods was an original but most horror fans didn't care for it. I liked Looper. Last ride. Hated Zero Dark thirty because it's all propaganda, fun film at end but I just don;t want to see films about the war on terror or any of that nonsense. It seems too soon for all those 911 films, the war genre is so old. Argo was boring. Ugh. Ironically the Oscars were tonight. lol

I miss good movies.
 

TheElkTreeFunk

Well-Known Member
This looks interesting. Spike Lee has vision, we will see.



[video=youtube_share;ZrLcnrnEqyI]http://youtu.be/ZrLcnrnEqyI[/video]
 
Top