First of all, make sure your ph pen is calibrated and accurate.
Cobby, Are you using the well water on other containers/ houseplants without any recent issues? Well/ municipal can fluctuate, but not drastically unless a severe weather event(hurricane/etc).
You said it's just the colder runs that are showing defs, warmer is fine ? , adding more cal/ mag will not solve the issues then.... Raising temps will
Good luck