Snake Oil, Horticultural Myths, Horticultural Urban Legends, and Persuaders

Oregon and most other states have regulatory agencies that examine fertilizers and hydroponics plant supplements to determine the legitimacy, ingredients and effectiveness of plant growth products.​

Advanced Nutrients co-founder Michael Straumietis welcomes the news that Oregon's government proffered formal approval for an Advanced Nutrients formula designed for a specific strain of medical marijuana.​

"Regulatory approval is a breakthrough for the medical marijuana community," Straumietis explains. "For the first time, government regulators have examined and affirmed the use of crop-specific medical marijuana hydroponics nutrients."​

Until Straumietis asked regulators to evaluate the medical marijuana effectiveness and safety of Advanced Nutrients hydroponics formulas, regulators nationwide had apparently never considered how hydroponics nutrients specifically affect medical marijuana crops.​

''It hasn't been part of the discussion, until now,'' Straumietis explains. "For example, when fertilizer regulators evaluate fertilizers that have labels claiming to produce larger tomatoes, they require specific efficacy data proving those claims. Now Oregon regulators have opened the door for formal evaluation of hydroponics nutrients and medical marijuana growth, quality and yield."​

Oregon medical marijuana patients, cultivators, doctors and advocates applauded the regulatory decision, citing their long-held concern that regulators were not looking at how hydroponics nutrients interact with medical marijuana.​

"Advanced Nutrients and the medical marijuana community give kudos to Oregon regulators for being the first state regulators to evaluate the science of medical marijuana and hydroponics nutrients," Straumietis says. "Our community is looking for similar action from regulators in other medical marijuana states."
[End Quote]
It was big news. According to Advanced Nutrients they had scored an industry coup. US agricultural regulators were now working with arguably the shadiest company in the hydroponics industry to boost illicit crop yields or, at least this is what Advanced Nutrients would have you believe.
However
A Letter to Advanced Nutrients from The Oregon Department of Agriculture

“June 17, 2010
ADVANCED NUTRIENTS

Click to expand...

Oregon Department of Agriculture
635 Capitol Street NE
Salem, OR 97301-2532
Sent by Certified Mail
NOTICE OF NONCOMPLIANCE
A recent Advanced Nutrients PR release titled, "Hydroponics Nutrients for Medical
Marijuana Gain Government Approval" (http://www.prnewswire.com/
news-releases/hydroponics-nutrients-for-medical-marijuana-gain-government-approval-95489084.html), with the company contact specified as Michael Straumietis, contains false and misleading claims concerning Advanced Nutrients products.
As I explained in a letter of February 23, 2010, to Advanced Nutrients, "labeling" means any printed or verbal representation used to promote the sale of any fertilizer,
agricultural mineral, agricultural amendment or lime product. Labeling includes, but is not limited to: sales presentations, brochures, posters, websites, printed advertisements, radio and television advertisements [ORS 633.311 (14)]. Press releases are a form of labeling.
Oregon statute [ORS 633.366(2)(a)] considers a product mislabeled if the label or
labeling is "false, misleading or deceptive." Using Webster's Third New International
Dictionary as a guide, a claim is misleading if it, "lead in a wrong direction or into a
mistaken action or belief." Further, in identifying "mislead" as a synonym to "deceive" the dictionary states that "mislead" "indicates a causing to fall into error of some sort,
intentionally or not." Products with labels or labeling using terms or claims that may
mislead a consumer are mislabeled, and prohibited under Oregon law.
1) This press release states, " .. . Oregon regulators have given first-ever official US approval to a brand of medical marijuana hydroponics nutrients ... "
The online version of the Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines approve as "to have or
express a favorable opinion of." Product registration means a product has met the
minimum requirements for sale or distribution in Oregon. No opinion, favorable or
otherwise, is expressed or implied. This statement, which applies to the entire
Advanced Nutrients brand, is false and misleading.
2) This press release states, " . . . Oregon regulators have given first-ever official US
approval to a brand of medical marijuana hydroponics nutrients ... " In fact, Oregon
has registered two Advanced Nutrients products with label claims stating the product
is for the production of medical marijuana. Individual products are registered for sale
or distribution , not brands. This claim, which applies to the entire Advanced Nutrients brand, is misleading.
3) The press release stated, "Until Straumietis asked regulators to evaluate the medical marijuana effectiveness and safety of Advanced Nutrients hydroponics formulas, regulators nationwide had apparently never considered how hydroponics nutrients specifically affect medical marijuana crops."
To date, Oregon has not received a request from Mr. Straumietis to "evaluate the
medical marijuana effectiveness and safety of Advanced Nutrients hydroponics
formulas .... " This labeling claim is false, and all "Advanced Nutrients hydroponic
formulas" may be considered mislabeled.
4) This press release stated, "Until Straumietis asked regulators to evaluate the medical marijuana effectiveness and safety of Advanced Nutrients hydroponics formulas , regulators nationwide had apparently never considered how hydroponics nutrients specifically affect medical marijuana crops."
This claim, that a state agency, which might be considered as an independent
evaluator, has evaluated and approved the safety of these products to produce
medical marijuana is false. This claim is also particularly disturbing, as it appears to be targeted to mislead a particularly vulnerable population, medical patients who have turned to medical marijuana in hope of some relief of their symptoms.
The claim that Oregon, the state referred to in the PR release, has evaluated the
effectiveness and safety of Advanced Nutrients hydroponics for use in the production of medical marijuana is false and misleading, and all "Advanced Nutrients hydroponic formulas" may be considered mislabeled…..
Don Wolf
Fertilizer Program Specialist
Oregon Department of Agriculture
503-986-4587
Fax: (503) 986-4735
For more information visit our website:
oregon.gov/ODAIPEST/fertilizer.shtml”
[End Quote]
View/download original correspondence (PDF)
I’ll post a lot more material shortly regarding the business practices of Advanced Nutrients so keep an eye on www.integralhydro.com for further updates. In the meantime (to shorten a long story)…
In Brief:​

Advanced Nutrients and the Oregon Department of Agriculture (the facts) ​

At present (October 2010) the ‘Oregon Department of Agriculture’ has issued Advanced Nutrients with five counts of stop sale violation, fifteen counts of selling unregistered products and eighteen counts of mislabeling. In addition, actions for sample deficiencies are in progress. ​

Prior to this, during the course of 2010 (Jan – Aug) Advanced Nutrients has been issued with numerous violation notices/penalties by the Oregon Department of Agriculture. ​

E.g. (Excerpts from FOIA material)
February 2010

“A recent review of advertising claims made by Advanced Nutrients in the
February 2010 issue of Rosebud: Hydroponic Growers' Lifestyle Magazine has
shown product claims that are inconsistent with the registered product label or
not compliant with Oregon Revised Statute (ORS) Chapter 633, Oregon's
fertilizer control law.
It is a violation of Oregon Revised Stature (ORS) 633.366(2)(d) to make claims in
product labeling that are inconsistent with the registered product label.”
[End Quote]
April/June 2010

“Advanced Nutrients 0-15-40 Big Bud
On April 29, 2009 the Department found this product being offered for sale or
distribution at Northern Light and Garden in Beaverton, Oregon. Subsequent analysis found it was deficient in magnesium (Mg), L-Arginine, L-Aspartic Acid, L-Glycine, LHistidine, L-Isoleucine, L-Leucine, L-Phenylalanine, L-Proline, L-Tyrosine, and L-Valine:
Constituent
Concentration (%)
Claimed on Label
Concentration Found
By Analysis
Available Phosphate
15
16.7
Soluble Potash
40
40.4
Magnesium
7.0
0.0148
Total Nitrogen
none claimed
0.944
Alanine - Total
0.3
0.348
Ammonia - Total
none claimed
0.225
Arginine - Total
0.8
0.194
Aspartic Acid-Total
1.2
0.770
Glutamic Acid-Total
0.4
1.23
Glycine - Total
0.7
0.146
Histidine - Total
0.4
0.132
Isoleucine - Total
1.1
0.475
Leucine - Total
0.9
0.747
Lysine - Total
0.2
0.624
Phenylalanine-TotaI
0.6
0.239
Proline - Total
0.7
0.394
Serine - Total
0.4
0.381
Threonine - Total
0.3
0.504
Tyrosine - Total
1.3
0.209
Valine - Total
1.1
0.413

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

…These deficiencies constituted false, misleading or deceptive label information, and the label did not accurately reflect the composition of the product, which was thus mislabeled in violation of ORS 633.366(1 )(a)…. “​

Results of Analysis – Heavy Metals (Big Bud)​

Element ​

Lab Method​

Results​

Results Submitted to Support Product Registration​

Arsenic (As)​

EPA 3050B, 6010B ​

16.2 ppm ​

0.8 ppm ​

Cadmium (Cd) ​

EPA 3050B, 6010B ​

< 5 ppm ​

< 0.1 ppm ​

Mercury (Hg)​

EPA 7471A​

< 0.2 ppm ​

< 0.001 ppm ​

Lead (Pb)​

EPA 3050B, 6010B ​

10.7 ppm ​

<0.5 ppm ​

Nickel (Ni)​

EPA 3050B, 6010B ​

< 5 ppm ​

0.6 ppm ​

[End Quote]​

Authorâ&#8364;&#8482;s note: Looking at the â&#8364;&#732;Results of Analysis â&#8364;&#8220; Heavy Metals (Big Bud)â&#8364;&#8482;, the HM (Heavy Metal) content found in Big Bud during independent tests is far higher than is stated by Advanced Nutrients. It is important to note that I make a recommendation in â&#8364;&#732;contaminants in cannabisâ&#8364;&#8482; (www.integralhydro.com/ advancednutrients), stating that Med dispensaries and/or growers should independently test fertilizers and not take manufacturer listings as fact. This is just one example of why I make this recommendation (there are many more). Further, the results of the HM tests indicate relatively contaminated synthetic fertilizers and/or organic components were used in production.​

May - July 2010

â&#8364;&#339;On July 12 2010, the Oregon Department of Agriculture (Department) conducted a marketplace inspection at Northern Light & Garden (9290 SW Beaverton-Hillsdale Hwy, Beaverton, OR 97005). During this inspection, the product(s) listed on the attached form were placed under an Oregon statewide Stop Sale, Use, or Removal. Order (SSURO).

Click to expand...

The Department hereby instructs Advanced Nutrients and/or its agents to immediately cease all sales, offers of sale, or distribution of the product(s) listed on the attached forms into or within Oregon, by any type of business transaction or other method.
â&#8364;¦It is a violation of Oregon Revised Statutes (ORS) 633.366(a) to sell, offer for sale, or distribute a fertilizer, agricultural amendment, agricultural mineral, or lime product that is mislabeled under ORS 633.321.
It is a violation of ORS 633.366(1)(e) to sell, offer for sale, or distribute unregistered fertilizer, agricultural amendment, agricultural mineral, or lime products in the State of Oregon.â&#8364;
[End Quote]
Products Listed in violation Jan â&#8364;&#8220; Aug 2010 ​

Advanced Nutrients, 0-2-4 Bud Ignitor (unregistered)​

Advanced Nutrients, Tarantula (unregistered)​

Advanced Nutrients, Voodoo Juice (mislabeled)​

Advanced Nutrients, Piranha (mislabeled)​

Advanced Nutrients, 0-0-1 Tarantula (mislabeled)​

5-0-1 Micro (unregistered)​

Bud Factor X (mislabeled)​

1-5-4 Overdrive (mislabeled) ​

0-2-4 Big Bud (liquid) (unregistered)​

0-0-13 Rhino Skin (unregistered) ​

4.8-1.8-4.3 Mother Earth Super Tea Grow (unregistered)​

50-1.50-2.0 Mother Earth Super Tea Bloom (unregistered)​

Grandma Energy's F-1 (mislabeled)​

1.5-1.5-1.5 Grandma Energy's Sensational Seaweed (unregistered)​

Grandma Energy's H-2 (mislabeled)​

0-0-0.5 Organic B (unregistered)​

Nirvana (mislabeled)​

2-1-6 Grow (unregistered)​

B-52 (no grade, no guaranteed analysis) (unregistered)​

3-1 -3 Organic Iguana Juice Grow (unregistered)​

Dr. Hornby Voodoo Juice Microbial Rhizosphere (unregistered)​

Bud Candy (unregistered)​

Juicy Roots (unregistered)​

0-0-13 Rhino Skin (unregistered)​

2-0-0 SensiCal Mg Calcium and Magnesium Bloom (unregistered)​

Sensi Grow (unregistered)​

Sensi Bloom (unregistered)​

Connoisseur (unregistered) ​

Keep in mind that at present â&#8364;&#8220; in addition to these violations â&#8364;&#8220; the â&#8364;&#732;Oregon Department of Agricultureâ&#8364;&#8482; has issued Advanced Nutrients with a further five counts of stop sale violation, fifteen counts of selling unregistered products, and eighteen counts of mislabeling. Actions for sample deficiencies are also in progress.​

View Stop Sale List on Oregon Site
Conclusion
What is clear is that Advanced Nutrients have no regard for consumer protection policies and regularly engage in misleading and deceptive marketing. In this case they have lowered the bar even further and utilized commercially depraved tactics in order to deceive consumers.
What is most worrying is that Advanced Nutrients have used two credible entities (PR Newswire and the Oregon Department of Agriculture) to support and amplify the deception. This form of parasitic marketing is likely to influence med growers, users and dispensaries re medical marijuana growing practices (something that Advanced Nutrients are all too aware of). One is also left wondering whether my earlier article (Hydro Hype 1) on Advanced Nutrients, their phosphorous myth, and â&#8364;&#732;Contaminants in Cannabisâ&#8364;&#8482;, published in Feb 2010 on www.integralhydro.com might not have inspired this latest outburst of grotesquely distorted marketing (I.e. parasitic marketing times three).
Further, as one Oregon Department of Agriculture representative put it â&#8364;&#339;This claim is also particularly disturbing, as it appears to be targeted to mislead a particularly vulnerable population, medical patients who have turned to medical marijuana in hope of some relief of their symptoms.â&#8364;
Magazines Connected to Advanced Nutrients
Rosebud (Advanced Nutrients)​

Websites Connected to Advanced Nutrients
http://www.advancednutrients.com
http://www.appliedagscience.com/
http://ezinearticles.com/?expert_bio=Michael_Straumietis
http://www.growersunderground.com
Read more about the business practices of Advanced Nutrients (Dubious Marketing in LaLa Land)​

Please note: The author has no affiliation to any hydroponics industry nutrient and additive manufacturer/s. The author has never accepted any advertising revenue from any manufacturer or other hydroponics industry entity (ever) and no â&#8364;&#732;Hydro Hypeâ&#8364;&#8482; story has been (or ever will be) influenced in any way by competition of any of the companies mentioned in â&#8364;&#732;Hydro Hypeâ&#8364;&#8482;. The aim of â&#8364;&#732;Hydro Hypeâ&#8364;&#8482; is to expose the rorts and scams that for far too long have taken place in an industry which has operated unhindered and unregulated by the consumer protection policies that underpin and govern the practices of other industries.

www.integralhydro.com - Knowledge is Power​

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Harrekin said:

A double whammy of holy horseshit! Jesus, I knew AN were scumbags, but that's not wink wink sneaky advertising, that's blatant lying and product misrepresentation.

This industry just keeps looking more and more fucked up to be honest.

Click to expand...

Conclusion
What is clear is that Advanced Nutrients have no regard for consumer protection policies and regularly engage in misleading and deceptive marketing. In this case they have lowered the bar even further and utilized commercially depraved tactics in order to deceive consumers.

Click to expand...

Uncle Ben said:

uhhhhhhh, duh

[/B][/B]

Click to expand...

Harrekin said:

.....Why isn't this info plastered everywhere? The mentioned products are literally "loop-hole legal" poison in a bottle..

Click to expand...

Ogsmokealot said:

UB, dont mean to hijack ur thread but after calculating my npk all together it comes out 23-12.4-36.2. Is this too high in K? im trying to get the yellowing and falling leaves to stop.

Click to expand...

Ogsmokealot said:

Thanks UB. Any thoughts on house and garden nutrient line up for soil?

Click to expand...

Samwell Seed Well said:

I come in peace

and what have you heard about Canna? and if you were suggesting a change in line up for someone using 100% coir what would it be, or would/should i switch to soil?

Click to expand...

Ogsmokealot said:

This is of topic UB but I really need some help here. can anyone help me calculate my npk?
Soil A is 2.3-0-2.3 @ 20ml
B is 1-1-3.6 @ 20ml
Drip clean 0-18-6 @ 1ml
BudXL 4-0-2 @ 7ml
Fish emulsion 4-1-1 @ 5ml
Bid bud powder 1-17-38 @ 2 grams
I added the fish to raise my N bc I have N def. Pls help!

Click to expand...

Uncle Ben said:

Hmmmmmm, let's see......what have I heard about Canna? A little bit of personal history is in order. I and a few others (potroast for one) have been posting about growing pot for well over a decade, before high tech internet and modern websites were around. First there was ADPC, a newsgroup, and then a real forum came along called marihemp aka cannabis.com designed by a fella by the name of Ron. It was a site where all the heavy weights in this new industry congregated - Vic High, Brothers Grimm, Sensi, Greenman, me, Newbie aka Lucas, etc. Lot's of chatter, some noise but it worked....for a while. I modded 7 forums by myself. There were only a handful of seedbanks back then. One of the first Dutch pot companies to post to cannabis.com was Canna, and they were hawking a product that I found most disgusting, harmful. Was probably the start of what I suspected was the future direction for this biz. But I digress.....Canna's main spokesman (the owner) and I went toe to toe in threads regarding C02 tabs he offered which were supposed to do things for pot that would make you go bonkers.....all the typical flowery fluff, claims, and bullshit. Problem? C02 gas happens to be toxic to any plant's root system. Didn't matter what botanical thought I presented, he was going to say the sky was mauve and you better believe it's true. So, here he is pimping these high priced worthless tablets, noobs are eating it up (as dreamy noobs do) not giving a shit about the community and ignoring common sense botany.

I was using coir 30 years ago with orchids before it became fashionable in lala land.

There's another problem with most if not all "cannabis specific" nute ratios - they are too damn high in K compared with N. I really don't think any of them know or care about plant nutrition as some of this stuff is just way over the top regarding its design..... and of course they design in the need for additives and boosters by making their "base" products deficient in the first place. It's a racket.

This is a concept you need to learn well, nutrient antagonism --> http://www.totalgro.com/concepts.htm
An overage of K will impede the uptake of 3 of the most important elements for good cannabis nutrition - N, Ca, Mg.

UB

Click to expand...

Harrekin said:

Ben with all due respect, one of their other pages states that some plants like a 1:2 ratio of N to K. http://www.totalgro.com/productprofiles.htm

Is there a nutrient profile for Cannabis that gives the perfect ratio required or is it guesswork on your part? Cos all plants have clearly different requirements (this is supported by the link above).

Thank you.

Click to expand...

Harrekin said:

If those are Advanced Nutrient products you can't reliably add up what the NPK is, because they lie on the labels.

UB just one more thing, I can't find a single hit anywhere about Canna CO2 soil tabs, maybe you're giving them a hard time for a case of mistaken identity?

Click to expand...