HenryTheEighth
Well-Known Member
I think Hitler and his Germany was a successful socialist population who revealed themselves as Fascists.Left is a broader category, spanning center-left, social democrats, and democratic socialists. I reserve the term far left for those who seek to collectivize the means of production, finance, communications etc. Uncompromising socialists, of whom communists were a subset in theory. In practice they (Leninists et al.) revealed themselves as fascists in a red suit.
I am unaware of a successful nation-scale socialist population in history.
My son, who has interest in nonauthoritarian sociopolitical systems, turned me onto these folks, who seem to be as close as I’ve seen. The downside to their society, as near as I can tell, is that it does not lend itself to high technology — and can only exist when bigger players let them be.
I recently had an argument with my partner about this.
She likes to believe Hitler was a Fascist.
I like to tell her Hitler sold socialism and never claimed to be Fascist. He had to use fascism to achieve socialism.
She nearly had a melt down because she needs to believe socialism is real on some level.
But like you say - point to where it’s happened successfully??
I said socialism will never be real while there are capitalists etc.
Therefore if ANYONE dreams of socialism you need to ask yourself how far are you prepared to go to TRULY get it? = Fascism OR walk away from the dream because you will never convince everyone as politics doesn’t work that way.