@Padawanbater2 Are you just going to back out of the thread now? And I'm curious why you chose the word "shaming." How on earth could shame be even measured to see if enough "shame" heaped on any given person was effective?
Now do you mean should our government find a way to tax people who engage in physically unhealthy behaviors? If you could convince me of a fair way to do that and WHO would qualify then I'd be all ears. I am not convinced that certain behaviors are diseases but It seems almost impossible to legislate an addiction tax or a fat tax, etc. I know we already have "sin" taxes on cigarettes and liquor, and I remember someone came up w/ an idea to put all those tax dollars into a fund so when the smoker got lung cancer, that's how he would pay his med. bills.
These things look good on paper, but when you extrapolate them out there are just too many variables and gray areas for it to work. Interested to hear your honest thoughts on your subject instead of lighting a match and walking away.