Zero root growth in 2 weeks.

rkymtnman

Well-Known Member
So 0.01 grams per gallon at 60% chlorine, mines 32% chlorine, so 0.02 g per gallon, how would I figure out liters? There's 4.56 liters to a gallon. I have to divide something right? Haha shit
sorry, i don't do math. lol.

it should smell like a swimming pool though but not strong enough to burn your nose hairs though.
 

rkymtnman

Well-Known Member
that is weird they give you such a range too. like on pool shock, it gives an exact % of cal hypo, not a range.
 

Bucsfan80

Well-Known Member
does it say what % of calcium hypo? i'm not sure if active chlorine is the same thing as % cal hypo. and too much chlorine will kill them quick
Yeah real quick, that's why I don't use it. I put to much (didn't know it used a ratio from here) and the roots would not touch the water and ended up losing the plant
 

Duhh

Active Member
Yeah real quick, that's why I don't use it. I put to much (didn't know it used a ratio from here) and the roots would not touch the water and ended up losing the plant
they been getting it for 2 weeks and they not dead, so it must be OK. Yes smells like a pool a bit when I put it in.
 

Duhh

Active Member
that is weird they give you such a range too. like on pool shock, it gives an exact % of cal hypo, not a range.
Yeah right i don't get it. I'm in UK so no pool shock and any hot tub cleaner pool cleaner had other ingredients so I found this just calcium hypochlorite, but yeah that range hey, weird.
 

Billy the Mountain

Well-Known Member
I know some have great results using chlorine and running sterile but I've had better luck with GFF (98.85% Bacillus amyloliquefaciens) in DWC.


4 days of root growth
signal-2020-06-23-20-55-20-922.jpgsignal-2020-06-27-11-00-41-617-1.jpg
 

Bucsfan80

Well-Known Member
Wow that's nice, how long did that take to grow those? Is that a product or just 98.85 Bacillus amyloliquefaciens? Do you have to keep the temps down using that as well? How much how often?
Yeah it's garden friendly fungicide from souther agricultural you can get away with a little higher temps with it
 

Duhh

Active Member
I've had good runs with gff and without but not sterile
It's my first time I just read too much about people having problems in the reservoir so I was just like no sterile.

What's GFF?

So using Bacillus amyloliquefaciens also prevents reservoir problems?
 

Billy the Mountain

Well-Known Member
I've had good runs with gff and without but not sterile
Same here
The pictures I posted above were after a bout with pythium. I chopped all the roots with a pair of scissors from both plants.
One plant got ~4ppm free chlorine, the other a heavy dose of GFF
The GFF plant recovered much more quickly

A sample size of one isn't very meaningful, but it was clear that bennies worked better in my circumstance
 

Duhh

Active Member
Yeah it's garden friendly fungicide from souther agricultural you can get away with a little higher temps with it
Ah gff got it. So the 98.85 %Bacillus amyloliquefaciens is from a certain company, southern agriculture?
 

Duhh

Active Member
Same here
The pictures I posted above were after a bout with pythium. I chopped all the roots with a pair of scissors from both plants.
One plant got ~4ppm free chlorine, the other a heavy dose of GFF
The GFF plant recovered much more quickly

A sample size of one isn't very meaningful, but it was clear that bennies worked better in my circumstance
Wow that's very different results sample size of 1 or not. Good stuff I think I'll try that. Is it available anywhere as just the Bacillus amyloliquefaciens or does it need to come from that company as a product ?
 

Duhh

Active Member
Southern Ag is the company
GFF is the product

GH Defguard is essentially the same product as well
Nice it's on amazon uk. So everything else is the same-ish? , temps all that, just use this product instead of a sterile res and it most likely will be a better result? Does this stuff do the same as a sterile res but in a different way? Fight any pathogens that would cause problems?
 

Duhh

Active Member
man I've seen so many pictures of people with sterile res full of roots tho, hm. These plants didnt start in dwc tho and I messed it all up a bit at the beginning.
 

Billy the Mountain

Well-Known Member
Nice it's on amazon uk. So everything else is the same-ish? , temps all that, just use this product instead of a sterile res and it most likely will be a better result? Does this stuff do the same as a sterile res but in a different way? Fight any pathogens that would cause problems?
It's the opposite approach to using chlorine

Sterile: kill the harmful (and everything else)
Bennies: out-compete the harmful with beneficial
 
Top