Look at your "little or no human effect" chart made by Hans von Storch, six years ago. Read what he has to say now. The Climate Science Capitulation Begins
Hans von Storch: We Definitely Have Seen Less Warming Than Expected
http://notrickszone.com/2013/09/11/the-climate-science-capitulation-begins-hans-von-storch-we-definitely-have-seen-less-warming-than-expected/ Georg Ehring of German Public Radio conducted an interview with climate scientist Professor Hans von Storch, Director of the German Coastal Research Center. The introductory text before the interview reads as follows:
The Earth has warmed considerably less than expected over the past 15 years days, says Hans von Storch. That may be due to an unforeseeable climate variability, or that CO2′s effect as a greenhouse gas was over-estimated, so says the meteorologist of the Coastal Research Institute. If anything, this interview shows that German climate science is beginning a slow shift and that warmist scientists starting to come to terms with the real possibility that they have been wrong all these years possibly very wrong. It also shows that they are admitting that climate is poorly understood. The science in nowhere near understood, let alone settled. On whether global warming has stopped, Hans von Storch says: No. We dont expect that. But it is indeed true that we have seen a considerably reduced warming trend compared to what our climate model scenarios showed over the last 15 years. [...]
We definitely have seen less warming than we expected. On what the cause could be, von Storch says many candidates are possible, and it points to climate variability, which would be natural fluctuations, which is what skeptics have been saying from Day 1. He also says that perhaps the climate sensitivity of CO2 was perhaps a bit over-estimated.
Hans von Storch even mentions the S-word, claiming that it could have something to do with the sun. WOOOPS