I don't even know what a Tacit Consent argument is, but hey, if you like, go ahead and splain it to me so that you can destroy it. I might even learn something. I'll help you get started by saying "I support the Tacit Consent argument, what do you say about that!"
Philosophy. Its a great way to sharpen the mind and to get people to consider alternatives. Its just that when others were studying Kant and those other guys I was studying math, chemistry, physics and so forth. As such, I'm more facts driven than philosophy driven. Hence my arguments are rooted in what has happened and in what people do rather than how things should be. That said, we need to improve our social systems and I don't know where else to look for better ideas. So, bring your philosophical musing forward but without concrete examples of how this actually works in human society, it seems hypothetical and is lost on me. You might as well quote the bible to me. I get totally lost when people do that.
I'm not aware of an example in history where your ideas were realized in larger communities. On a smaller scale, if coercion is used to prevent gangs from controlling my street and hazarding my children then I'm all for it. Your ideas have been tried in small communal farms, but those don't usually last. A reason for this, i think, is that your ideas are not rooted in human behavior. Over time, human society has developed means other than coercion to keep us from doing each other wrong. This is all for the better but we've never been free from this element of control.
In fact, even our cousins in the primate world don't show any inclination to live in a world free of authority backed by force. The alpha male is pretty commonly a rough leader. This is why I think that your philosophy is more cerebral rather than practical.
I grew up in a pretty rough and tumble family. I love my brothers but most of the time we weren't very nice to each other. I've grown a pretty thick skin. I kind of enjoy a sharp debate and can give and take abuse. If you get aggravated and need to vent, do it with intelligence and humor and I'll be ok with it.