Cheapest water cooling option

MeGaKiLlErMaN

Well-Known Member
Ive seen a few and I know it almost seems as hard as getting into DIY lights but its just as simplistic. If you are interested I have a sample available with some a few options that you can do.

The first is to hook up everything and let the radiator sit in with your reservoir so that it can be chilled as it dissipates heat.

The second is mounting the radiator on either the top of the light or on a wall.

The third (that I wouldn't recommend) is to treat the coolant as you would exhaust air and have an in and an out from the room, this would be the best long term solution but you would most likely get wet dissembling it.



So what do you need?


$80-120 - A GOOD water pump (its meant for computers so do NOT use ones for gardening unless you know what you're doing) you can find them cheaper... but this is where you dont want to skimp. You can get creative if you feel confident.


$45-120 - Radiator acts the same as the one on your car, uses liquid to remove heat from where ever you have the coolant running through.

$6-20 - Waterblocks, simple things but you will need to either use compression fittings or another way to clamp these down snugly as there is a good bit of pressure running though these lines.

cheap - Tubing 1/2in black will work fine, same stuff used for hydro

$10-15 -12VDC - an external power supply to run the pump and any fans you choose to use on the radiator.

$123 - 0.25in(rounded up) aluminum sheet that will support the light and act as a solid mounting surface. a bit over kill but you get the idea.


Now for this example Im using a light that really doesnt need the cooling that Im showing, this would be for if you wanted to run full boar or close to it, also this isnt a NEED its more of a "because why the fuck not?"


__________________________________________________________________________________________________

CXB3590DD36V5000K 10 COBS @2.4A ON 1.813 PROFILE HEATSINK
16 SQ.FT. CANOPY 92% EFFICIENT DRIVER @15 CENTS PER KWH
Total power watts at the wall: 952.17
Cobs power watts: 876
Total voltage forward: 365
Total lumens: 152477
Total PAR watts assuming 10% loss: 424
Total PPF: 1895.28
PPFD based on canopy area: 1275.04
PAR watts per sq.ft.: 26.5
Cob efficiency: 53.72%
Power watts per sq.ft.: 54.75
Voltage forward per cob: 36.48
Lumens per watt: 174.06
Heatsink riser thickness / number of fins / fin's length: 0.3in/6/0.95in
Heatsink area per inch: 100.94 cm^2
Total heat watts: 405
umol/s/W / CRI: 4.47 / 70CRI
Heatsink length passive cooling @120cm^2/heatwatt: 481 inches
Heatsink length active cooling @40cm^2/heatwatt: 160 inches
COB cost dollar per PAR watt: $1.1
Electric cost @12/12 in 30 days: $51.92
Electric cost @18/6 in 30 days: $77.63
Cost per cob: $46.5
Heatsink cost per inch cut: $0.66
Total cobs cost: $465
Total heatsink passive cooling cost: $317 (keep this number in mind)
Total heatsink active cooling cost: $105

__________________________________________________________________________________________________



The numbers for the passive are close to the water cool numbers, but with watercooling you would increase the efficiency even more. I cant see these going over 80F honestly.. With the water being chilled. Liquid is the most efficient way to cool something hot down.

So how the hell do you mount them to a .25in thick piece of metal? How would you tap the holes when there's going to be a water block behind it?

Easy, thermal adhesive.

You would not believe me if I told you how many times Ive used this stuff, but it works and is PERMANENT. Your cobs will NOT be coming off until you throw the light out, but that wont be for years. Im sure you could use shot screws and a thicker metal but it wouldn't be cost effective.

So the cost of everything... kinda pricey? yeah.. but its COBs this is an investment for the investment... so it will last much longer at a lower temp.

The install of everything is pretty straight forward, adhere the leds to one side of the panel spaced to your liking, then on the other side mount the water blocks with the in and outlets facing inboard to make the tubing connect easily. The pump can be set up anywhere but its impotant to understand that these pumps have very little height pumping capabilities... so dont put a long run going straight up. The system should pull water out of the reservoir and pump it into the heatsinks, then it goes into the radiator and back to the reservoir.

Thats really it, like I said mind the long runs or choose a higher end pump. The one below it for long term use and being kept in short runs like inside the grow room to a wall mounted radiator.




Total estimated cost:$1,131



(assuming you have the tubing)

LEDS: $465
Drivers: depends on how you want to run them but $250 sounds like a safe number
Cooling total: $386


So for around $1131 you can have a kick ass light that puts out some photons and is watercooled. This is not for everyone but any people that love messing with things will get addicted.



cooling.jpg cooling metal.jpg

 

MeGaKiLlErMaN

Well-Known Member
Also if anyone's interested in this I can help through PMs on a more specific level.. Everyone's different, but this should be able to cool 100W of heat per water block. So this is a good first step.
 

BM9AGS

Well-Known Member
So you're using waterblocks on an aluminum sheet and then having the cobs on the other side? So 2x thermal loss from TIM?

I've looked and looked for CPU waterblocks and chipset waterblocks to match up with a 3590 but couldn't find any. Maybe would work for a CLU 58.
 

MeGaKiLlErMaN

Well-Known Member
So you're using waterblocks on an aluminum sheet and then having the cobs on the other side? So 2x thermal loss from TIM?

I've looked and looked for CPU waterblocks and chipset waterblocks to match up with a 3590 but couldn't find any. Maybe would work for a CLU 58.
A standard water block can do 100W of heat. You could also cut the aluminum and have direct contact. the aluminum would be cool anyways because The water cools more than the heat produced so it's not a big deal. So as its produced the heat is taken away by the aluminum that is cooler and any heat past that is taken by the coolant.
 

loftygoals

Well-Known Member
It's great you're enthusiastic and all but I would recommend you build one of these lights and run it for a few months to appreciate the issues which will arise before recommending other people build something out of those parts.

You give the impression that you've already done this but your parts list is kinda half baked and *will not all fit together*.

Your tubing (1/2 inch) will not fit the barbs on your waterblocks (8mm). Hose clips need to be selected to account for tube thickness too.

Your choice of water pump is a bit strange as it is meant to be plugged in to a computer PSU and start/stop at the same time as your PC. If you wanted a "computer water cooling" standard pump there are better choices that would do the job without messing with 12V power converters and splicing new connectors together. I chose an Eheim 1250 as I was comfortable with Eheim (ran one of their pumps for years in an old watercooled PC rig).

You can buy the waterblocks much cheaper on ebay or direct from the manufacturer (smartbes on alibaba).

You will need a beefy radiator/fan to cope with that much heat. You haven't picked out a radiator. What thermal adhesive are you recommending? These are not minor details.

As I said it's great that you're enthusiastic about it... but build it, figure out all the issues, then come tell us about it. "Recommending" stuff to people when it's all just a dream in your head is setting *other people* up to fail. Which is not cool IMO. If you had posted a "what do people think of this potential setup?" thread... that would have been cool.

(FWIW I am on my third iteration of my water cooled COBs and have been at it for 10 months now... which is why red flags are popping up in my head when I read through your plan)
 

MeGaKiLlErMaN

Well-Known Member
It's great you're enthusiastic and all but I would recommend you build one of these lights and run it for a few months to appreciate the issues which will arise before recommending other people build something out of those parts.

You give the impression that you've already done this but your parts list is kinda half baked and *will not all fit together*.

Your tubing (1/2 inch) will not fit the barbs on your waterblocks (8mm). Hose clips need to be selected to account for tube thickness too.

Your choice of water pump is a bit strange as it is meant to be plugged in to a computer PSU and start/stop at the same time as your PC. If you wanted a "computer water cooling" standard pump there are better choices that would do the job without messing with 12V power converters and splicing new connectors together. I chose an Eheim 1250 as I was comfortable with Eheim (ran one of their pumps for years in an old watercooled PC rig).

You can buy the waterblocks much cheaper on ebay or direct from the manufacturer (smartbes on alibaba).

You will need a beefy radiator/fan to cope with that much heat. You haven't picked out a radiator. What thermal adhesive are you recommending? These are not minor details.

As I said it's great that you're enthusiastic about it... but build it, figure out all the issues, then come tell us about it. "Recommending" stuff to people when it's all just a dream in your head is setting *other people* up to fail. Which is not cool IMO. If you had posted a "what do people think of this potential setup?" thread... that would have been cool.

(FWIW I am on my third iteration of my water cooled COBs and have been at it for 10 months now... which is why red flags are popping up in my head when I read through your plan)

All fair point and noted, I have don't a lot of water cooled PCs and xbox360s and I didn't notice the inlet issue. Again this would work but the part need to be adjusted. The price is still close but I'll revise once in off work.
 

nevergoodenuf

Well-Known Member
@Shugglet Weight. This is one of the lightest lights I have built and I had 270+ watts worth of cooling each COB. $70 to cool 330 watts from one COB. Your right I don't see any advantages.
 

Shugglet

Well-Known Member
@Shugglet Weight. This is one of the lightest lights I have built and I had 270+ watts worth of cooling each COB. $70 to cool 330 watts from one COB. Your right I don't see any advantages.
I guess Ive never considered weight when building a light... ever. I would never hang em from something like drywall though lol ;)

I would just think the average person is more concerned about cost than weight of their light, that's all.

The main advantages I think of when I think of water cooling is generally space savings and the ability to actively chill the water being pumped through them. Theyre also typically quieter than an air cooled setup.
 

Shugglet

Well-Known Member
You will need a beefy radiator/fan to cope with that much heat. You haven't picked out a radiator. What thermal adhesive are you recommending? These are not minor details.
This needs quoted for importance. Not once did he discuss how the heat was being removed, just that the water blocks were capable of removing 100w of heat. Which may be true, but depends entirely upon how that ~100w of heat is actually REMOVED from the system after it has been added. Hence the significance of the radiator.
 

THE KONASSURE

Well-Known Member
just by an inflatable hot tub and a pump pump between that and your res

in summer a freezer full of cool packs is all you need, cool anysize hydro for almost nothing if you can use 10x the water and put a huge res in a cool spot
 

THE KONASSURE

Well-Known Member
Or a dehumidifier as a water chiller
them plug in coolers work well as a chilled res too

I have an aircon unit that condensates so much it could probably flow 6 to 20 large sacks, thing used to put out 4L to 10L a day and that`s a little home unit, lol

Bloody thing was like the Freemen caves in Dune, lol
 
Top