I did not mean to imply you promoted the over use of BSM. Just an interesting thread. And as far as the 'liquid carbon'.. Does something being water soluble actually make it a liquid? Most would say n
https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/6068/what-is-known-about-liquid-carbon
I doubt any of our grow temps are 4500 kelvin. Not to mention the incredible pressures involved.Its a long stretch to consider water soluble organis carbon as liquid carbon.
And by my response about the use of BSM is the same. I think its abused and over applied by many growers thinking it is a magic potion. Just my opinion.
And thanks for your link. I look forward to reading it when I am around my laptop.