@ANC:
As a BB myself, most of the ‘early‘ stuff was mobile-suit-based, and I’ve *NEVER* been able to get into those (the five-minute transformation scenes are THE WORST), though I have enjoyed a few (Knights of Sidonia/NFLX). More than anything else, anime is a way of telling stories, and it’s wired to a Japanese cultural matrix that leaves most ‘westerners’ completely adrift.
Key genres in anime are shonen (coming-of-age for boys), shoujo (coming-of-age for girls), seinen (end-of-childhood/brink-of-adulthood); the fundamental tropes include isekai (lost/reborn in different world), fantasy/gaming/roleplaying, slice-of-life (all kinds of life), mystery, horror, supernatural, romance, comedy, music, action/adventure, military, ‘historical’. These tropes, and their target/subject genres, get mixed up pretty thoroughly. The result is a wild variety of stories and narrative viewpoints - which often slide from one trope or genre to another.
For me, the storytelling is the key, so I’ll watch nearly anything - at least for a while; yes, I’ve been disappointed, but much more often I’m left laughing, exhilarated, pondering - and/or in tears…and glad I flipped the coin and just watched it. So much of it is genuinely excellent, brilliantly written, visualized and enacted (Japanese voice-actors are *famous* and have followings), and presented with incredible skill and nuance and variety. Plenty is ordinary to sloppy, derivative, or just not well-conceived, and it depends as much on production era as on any other factor: improvements in technology have taken anime from crude/simplistic to complex/dazzling/psychedelic, just as world events and cultural shifts have changed the stories and their telling along the way.
Speaking as an old man (‘67-edition hippie), having the last two years to fill, being able to share the quirks and pangs of Japanese teenagers as they struggle with school and puberty, of high-school nebbishes thrown into a world where they know nothing, understand nothing, and have to survive thru wit, grit, and determination, of discovering that their own comfortable world can be a cruel, scary, and dangerous place, has been oddly healing for me. A new perspective on adolescence, has given me a chance to rework some of the things that I ‘got wrong’ growing up…and that’s been pretty incredible.
I hesitate to recommend anything to you at this point, but if you just want to dive in somewhere, Cowboy Bebop & Samurai Champloo (yes, really) are classics: limited characters to follow, intertwined threads enlarging the stories, and limited episodes, more like complete miniseries than endless, ongoing story.
Assuming you’re interested enough to read this…either way, welcome to the conversation
(this is all just my opinion, and there’s tons I don’t know)