I read it otherwise: the people in the echo chamber are not moderate Republicans, but (in his take) Democrats, who are “the left” only by comparison. I could be wrong.
Liberals in the GOP were rendered listed as extinct by the relentless agency (since Bonzo) of Unnatural Selection.
I don’t disagree on any point.
I do remember, circa 1988, that I was seeing a pattern in the extreme-right chatter (of the derivative talking-point variety). The through line was essentially ‘all democrats do is lie, they lie about everything: they hate god, they hate this country, they hate YOU…lucky for you, *WE* are onto them, we know what their lies really mean, so DONT LISTEN TO THEM - listen to US…WE will tell you what they’re doing & what they mean & we’ll explain it all to you…so you don’t get confused’.
Sound familiar? It worked outrageously, & it came from media, from family, from bosses, from preachers, from suppliers, from politicians. It really ramped up during the ‘90 campaigns, and went on the offensive when Gingrich took over the House.
it’s provided the gaping gullets required to flood the zone w/ bullshit, and it’s crystallized into what I’ve called the imaginary liberal: said creature is stupid, greedy, craven, evil…wildly clever, tho - they’re commie masterminds who control everything (while stupid & evil) despite GOP dominating the federal level for most of the last 40 years (it’s why “we need more MAGA in office”: only a takeover will oust the demonic Dems). Fortunately, big spenders on bibles, televangelism, & MAGA “collectibles” can rely on the imaginary liberal being SO afraid of conflict, confrontation, & firearms that they piss themselves & curl into weeping balls when faced w/ righteous playtriotism.
That mythical ‘composite’ “democrat” - criminal, race-traitor, pedophile, willing agent of destruction, incompetent master of the world - doesn’t exist. It was made up. It was made up on purpose: to energize & weaponize the beliefs, prejudices, & assumptions of post-Confederate Confederates. It’s been deliberately poured down as many gullets as could be found, over and over, for decades, “from every corner of the building”. When Trump arrived, they turned it all over to him & did EVERYTHING they could think of to pursue *their* overthrow agenda while hiding behind the big loud ape.
The entire PARTY is culpable in the overthrow effort: accessories & accomplices before, during, and after the entire effort to scare normal people into giving “conservatives” enough power & numbers to take the nation, their vote, their weapons, their citizenship CLEAN AWAY FROM THEM. And us, sure, but we’re not devoted to being told we’re *not seeing what we’re seeing; they aren’t talking TO us, ever…or their ‘base’, really.
ASIDE: it’s kinda like the way “Bible study” has changed since the Gold-Plated Age. It was all about understanding how to live a better life, be a better person by learning from the gospels; now, it’s devolved into brainwashing sessions: the reading now includes what it means in terms of political beliefs and imaginary policies (like “open borders”). Living a Christ-like life is no longer ‘operational’…and somehow, when asking/asked “what would Jesus do?”, they show a COMPLETE lack of knowledge about the Jesus of the gospels, the magic inerrant word of gawd.
No real surprise that the degeneration of Christianity & of ‘conservativism’ have gone hand-in-hand
WITHOUT it, Trump insanity & the MAGA frenzy could never have gained purchase & influence as it has, could not have overridden the *real* patriotism, otherwise-working brains, & actual humanity of so many otherwise perfectly decent, ordinary folks, could not have spent generations warping our government so it would bend to their purposes when “the leader” (Der Fuhrer”) arrived.
Gawd I really DO go on sometimes
To sum up: I actually agree with the bulk of his post, only his vector is off by 180; like many others trip into the Upside-Down…the result being, ‘all right-side-up people are wrong’.
He’ll probably stay as wrong until/unless he begins to do some real research - and some questioning of those he’s never actually questioned
Thank you for your patience