^^^^^^^ Yeah, I looked at the MSDS and it doesn't look any different that most other fungicides or pesticides...... or very much different than Exel LG either for that matter. The Eagle 20 says that skin contact merely causes irritation same as Exel LG. And that prolonged exposure is unlikely to cause absorption of anything harmful. It has low toxicity if swallowed even. That being said, it contains small amounts of Napthalene which has been labeled by the International Agency for Research on Cancer as a "possible carcinogenic substance" . The U.S. EPA has placed naphthalene in Group D: NOT classifiable as a carcinogen (U.S. EPA, 1994a). The International Agency for Research on Cancer has NOT classified naphthalene for its carcinogenicity (IARC, 1987a).
At worst, in some cases LARGE AMOUNTS of VERY PROLONGED EXPOSURE of a single trace ingredient (OVER 2 STRAIGHT YEARS OF NEARLY NON-STOP VAPOR EXPOSURE) caused SOME rats to exhibit evidence of carcinogenic activity. And we're talking pure Napthalene. Besides this, once in the atmosphere, naphthalene rapidly photodegrades (half-life 3-8 hr). And AGAIN, we're talking direct application of this chemical which Eagle 20 contains trace amounts of...... which cigarette smoke also contains.
Point being, you can get the stuff on your skin and in your eyes with mild irritation, you can drink the shit and not get ill..... just don't distill the napthalene out....... become a 3 ounce rat and huff it and bathe in it for two years.... or you could possibly get sick, lol. Point is, the stuff is perfectly acceptable to use in the vegetative plant state and probably in the first few weeks of flowering for that matter. Anything in it that could possibly be harmful is perfectly safe in trace amounts and perfectly safe since it rapidly breaks down as well. I can't say what works or not if I haven't tried it, but if you have fungal problems Eagle 20 can and will cure it with no messing around.
Oh my goodness.
You made a bunch of shit up, mixed in your opinions, and then stated it all like its all fact.
Tristyn, I respectfully ask that you check the MSDS's against overgrows statements, and consider banning him, if making things up, mixing it with opinion, throwing in a red herring (naphthalene) then presenting it as fact is a bannable offense. (Your profile says you are a mod, hence the request here.)
Please, everyone. Read the MSDS's.
Don't take my word for it, READ THEM.
Napthalene is the least of your worries on that shit.
Here are my assertions:
Eagle 20's MSDS is not at all like "Most other fungicides", to say it is far too general to have any real possibility of usefulness in the context of this discussion.
Drinking it would be a very very very bad idea. Refer to the section of the MSDS "Note to physician"
Getting it on your skin is a pretty bad idea, too....see "Exposure Guidelines", and the paragraph below it.
Eagle 20 is so toxic, you should not store it NEAR food or water ...not even near it, in a closed fucking container. (see "Storage")
There's more, but hopefully, that is enough to get something done.
Listen, I would love a one stop solution to the leaf spot issue, but Eagle 20 is clearly way more toxic....If someone on RIU wants to make the decision to use a product after weighing the pros and cons, then that is cool. I know there are people who have different feelings than I about toxicity, and we should respect other peoples opinions, if we want our own to be respected.
But that rant about Eagle 20 was clearly intentionally misleading, to say the least. Spreading lies like that does us all a disservice.