Best hydroponic system for indoor

What is the best hydroponic system for a 4x4 tent and a 4x8 tent? Looking for the most efficient system that produces the best quality possible ☺
 
Would an ebb and flow work better as compared to a DWC system? Given that I grow indica plants in an apartment and will be using:
  • 1 vivosun 8" 720 CFM
  • 1 ipower 8" air carbon filter, 20" length
  • General hyrdoponic control kit for nutes
  • 1 active air ACSC duct fan
  • 4 skygenius battery operated clip fan
 

Jon E. Doe

Well-Known Member
Dude, Between the posts you've put up you have it a an abundantly clear that you will not be using the search function, or bother reading any by threads except your own.

There is no "correct" answer to you queries as you've not really given enough operation parameter to consider.

If you were to ask, I'd say you need an education rather my than a shopping list and step by step instructions.

In any case, I wish you the best of luck with your growing.
 

MickFoster

Well-Known Member
Would an ebb and flow work better as compared to a DWC system? Given that I grow indica plants in an apartment and will be using:
  • 1 vivosun 8" 720 CFM
  • 1 ipower 8" air carbon filter, 20" length
  • General hyrdoponic control kit for nutes
  • 1 active air ACSC duct fan
  • 4 skygenius battery operated clip fan
I'll give you the same answer that I did to the same question on GC. Coco Coir. Happy growing.
 
I run a 2 site homemade recirculating dwc system in my 4x4 that does great. I recently started a top drip sea of green grow in coco that I'm very impressed with in a 3x3 tent. I started out in coco hand feeding and done very well. I suggest starting there.
 

chemphlegm

Well-Known Member
they all work very well and they all have different user involvement.
one that cannot leak on the floor is a good first choice. like a flood/drain
my first was a low profile that fit perfectly into a 2x4 and held 12 plants with ease
 

since1991

Well-Known Member
Ive built or used just about every hydroponic "system" (its really different automated methods of nutrient solution delivery - thats all hydroponics basically is) and settled on top drip to waste using either coco coir or rockwool as the medium substrate. There is a reason its the default method for the vast majority of real pro cannbis cultivators (not home hobby growers) . Not many of them run NFT..Aero..or goofy bucket setups. But these are bigger growers as well. Flood and drain would be my other option if I was reusing the spent solution after one pass. Flood and drain for me was particularly awesome for my veg rooms as I run a perpeutual true seperate veg and flower rooms. And I might bust out my old flood and drain tables and slap them in my veg areas again sometime soon. I hand water with a wand, pump , & tank for now in veg. Iam a lazy fuck and flood and drain in veg suits me just fine. But hands down...coco coir or Rockwool in drip to waste. No question. And with 20 plus years under my belt...ive used them all at one time or another. Built quite a few as well.
 

since1991

Well-Known Member
What is the best hydroponic system for a 4x4 tent and a 4x8 tent? Looking for the most efficient system that produces the best quality possible ☺
The system itself is last on the criteria for quality. Quality is genetics first off..and grower skill and ability second. Then light and after that...systems and equipment...way down on the list. With super top shelf genetics...a noob rookie with subpar skills and gear can still pull off something smokable. With shit garbage genetics...Ed Rosenthal with a turn key state of the art warehouse operation no expense spared will not pull off anything but turds.
 

Dr. Who

Well-Known Member
Ive built or used just about every hydroponic "system" (its really different automated methods of nutrient solution delivery - thats all hydroponics basically is) and settled on top drip to waste using either coco coir or rockwool as the medium substrate. There is a reason its the default method for the vast majority of real pro cannbis cultivators (not home hobby growers) . Not many of them run NFT..Aero..or goofy bucket setups. But these are bigger growers as well. Flood and drain would be my other option if I was reusing the spent solution after one pass. Flood and drain for me was particularly awesome for my veg rooms as I run a perpeutual true seperate veg and flower rooms. And I might bust out my old flood and drain tables and slap them in my veg areas again sometime soon. I hand water with a wand, pump , & tank for now in veg. Iam a lazy fuck and flood and drain in veg suits me just fine. But hands down...coco coir or Rockwool in drip to waste. No question. And with 20 plus years under my belt...ive used them all at one time or another. Built quite a few as well.
It's all basically opinion, for the most part eh?

For new growers.
4x4 Ebb (flood and drain)

4x8 and have some experience?
RDWC Massive plants can be done in open spaces with this. You'll use less nutrient too. Might have to dump and refill more often. Not to mention be familiar with how to "top off" and it's variable methods of.

Might just consider the top drip to be the thing to master for ease of use and quality result. Well, now were back to opinion again....

Screw it. I'll stick with soil....:mrgreen:
 

Olpacdonald

New Member
Ive built or used just about every hydroponic "system" (its really different automated methods of nutrient solution delivery - thats all hydroponics basically is) and settled on top drip to waste using either coco coir or rockwool as the medium substrate. There is a reason its the default method for the vast majority of real pro cannbis cultivators (not home hobby growers) . Not many of them run NFT..Aero..or goofy bucket setups. But these are bigger growers as well. Flood and drain would be my other option if I was reusing the spent solution after one pass. Flood and drain for me was particularly awesome for my veg rooms as I run a perpeutual true seperate veg and flower rooms. And I might bust out my old flood and drain tables and slap them in my veg areas again sometime soon. I hand water with a wand, pump , & tank for now in veg. Iam a lazy fuck and flood and drain in veg suits me just fine. But hands down...coco coir or Rockwool in drip to waste. No question. And with 20 plus years under my belt...ive used them all at one time or another. Built quite a few as well.
Do you have any suggestions on set ups now that it’s been about 7 years lol. Switching from soil and there’s so many methods I’m not sure which set up to go with but what you’re saying sounds right to me
 

coreywebster

Well-Known Member
Do you have any suggestions on set ups now that it’s been about 7 years lol. Switching from soil and there’s so many methods I’m not sure which set up to go with but what you’re saying sounds right to me
Since 1991 has unfortunately not logged on since 2018.

But go with a system that Is least fancy.
A simple drain to waste with coco is fairly fool proof.
 
Last edited:

pegboy

Well-Known Member
Old school Ebb and Flow. Super simple. One res and one pump (and an air stone if you want). The only down side is that you have to top flush about once a week or so to combat salt build up. Maybe not the best but pretty foolproof as well.

IMG_20240518_074319342.jpgIMG_20240518_074327451.jpgIMG_20240518_074345100.jpg
 

conor c

Well-Known Member
For qaulity alone id go with coco coir ime it produces the best smoke vs other hydro methods its a close 2nd to dirt imo
 

grig_r1

Member
For qaulity alone id go with coco coir ime it produces the best smoke vs other hydro methods its a close 2nd to dirt imo
Not as close as you'd think,coco coir has better water retention and drainage than plain dirt, which allows for better root growth and if you care enough for the enviorment and all that,coco coir is also a renewable source if you think about it.
 

conor c

Well-Known Member
Not as close as you'd think,coco coir has better water retention and drainage than plain dirt, which allows for better root growth and if you care enough for the enviorment and all that,coco coir is also a renewable source if you think about it.
But soil/compost produces the best smoke quality imo you may be right about the other aspects but thats what counts for me the most
 
Top