Consistent effort. That's what I'd like to see from him. Honestly, I haven't watched any games this series, but I did catch a couple Caps games from round 1, and he was floating whenever he didn't have the puck. That's not what a captain of a team should be doing in playoffs. He has had ZERO success in the post season where the intensity gets turned up, and I question his heart/character because of it.
Yes he shoots the puck a shit-ton (too much if you ask me), and yes he battles *at times* when he has a chance to get the puck, but have you watched him away from the play? He doesn't hustle on the back check, and he's constantly staring at the puck leaving guys wide open in dangerous areas of the ice. If you want to see what a true captain plays like in the playoffs, watch a guy like Dustin Brown with the Kings, or even your boy Callahan with the Rangers. Those guys are willing to pay the price to win a championship. I don't see that from Ovechkin.
There's a reason why he's been in and out of the doghouse with his coaches.