You fail to understand the issue at hand here, not regulating the Internet will turn it into a free for all. Ultimately it would stifle competition and tech companies so badly that it is a NET LOSS for the entire planet if it remains a non-utility.
Currently: broadband is unregulated, traffic flows freely to and from all sources at the same rate. Video traffic is the same importance as university data, same as emails. Everything is not priced according to the type of data, why would it be? All types of data require the same amount of ONs and OFFs, the electricity requirement is exactly the same bit for bit.
If things were allowed to be run by comcast:
All data could be priced according to an arbitrary number from someone's ass.
Massive additional fees will results in the inability of small business to have a web presence.
Not getting the Internet turned into a utility would be a nightmare for our economy.