Well I can say as someone going from 3.5 gallon hempys using AN 3 part, building my no till garden is coming out way more then if I was going to do DWC. Seems like every time i find something local i get told it sucks. So putting this together and sourcing all the stuff is a headache. Especially in small town usa.
For instance, I found some local compost. Local company picks up food (cafeterias, hospitals and such) and yard waste from the local community and makes compost out of it. Saves like 15000 tons of stuff in the landfill. But was in formed it would be shit because of pesticides and "poison" was the term used. EWC ONLY. And only good ones. that you cant find anywhere.
and then the prices that were listed. id like to see where you can order 1 cu ft of "quality" EWC for $40 shipped to me. But even still, im making 18 cu ft of soil. So i need 6 of ewc. @$40 bucks a ft., im still looking at $240. Where as the local compost $2.88 for 2 cu ft. Or i set up enough bins, so maybe in a year i can make my soil from my own ewc. Still going to spend money on setting that up.
And then there's aeration. Dont use perlite in no tills. LOL of course not. I can get THAT local and cheap. Instead use pumice, lava rock, oyster shells, and or some biochar.
Well AWESOME. Pumice? Garden centers and nursery's either dont have it, or dont even know what the hell it is. Lava rock. SURE i can get that local. In Rock form. Big enough to beat a man to death with. So ill get 3 cu ft of lava rock, then i got at least 4+ hours breaking it all down to small form for my soil. Bio char is cheap, 10 bucks at walmart. But ill also need to spend time breaking that down. And who the hell knows how many gallons a 50 lb bag is. So either ill buy more then i need, or not enough.
Or i could go to one website, order everything i need to make a 12 site RDWC system for around 250 bucks. Plus chiller for 400. And nutes.
All this was a lot cheaper till i found out that i shouldnt do no tills in 7 gallon buckets but rather 15+. And why am i still going organic in spite of this colossal pain in the ass you may ask? Because imo, Organically grown cannabis and food tastes better then hydroponics.
End Rant