bongrippinbob
Well-Known Member
If you want something that is tested, and you know will work, I'd say go with a pre built one. If you don't mind doing a little experimenting with CFMs, carbon bed size, etc, then you can build one for much cheaper.
Most of the people that don't get good results from the homemade ones are people that didn't experiment at all. They built one, ran their fan through it, it didn't work, so it sucks. It could have just been too much carbon, too little carbon, too much CFM, etc.
So like I said, if you want something that will work pretty much perfect, buy a pre made filter. If you like to tinker, adjust, test, etc, then build yourself one. The homemade ones are built with the same design as the expensive ones, so if made correctly, they will work just fine.
Most of the people that don't get good results from the homemade ones are people that didn't experiment at all. They built one, ran their fan through it, it didn't work, so it sucks. It could have just been too much carbon, too little carbon, too much CFM, etc.
So like I said, if you want something that will work pretty much perfect, buy a pre made filter. If you like to tinker, adjust, test, etc, then build yourself one. The homemade ones are built with the same design as the expensive ones, so if made correctly, they will work just fine.