stardustsailor
Well-Known Member
I'think I'll get some sleep ....
And probablycontinue later on ...
And probablycontinue later on ...
I found a grow on RIU with astirs with about 1,6g/W.
So if cree and western chips are even much more efficient then those, should there not be 1,8g/W-2g/W grows all around by experienced users with A51 and Hanspanels?
Havent found those, but maybe I was looking at the wrong places?
Ha-ha-ha !!!
You're absoloutely right !
But ...Let us see some ..parameters ...
1) I' done myself some tests with a seemingly weird outcome :
I've found out that 3 x Astir panels ASL flowering ( each panel has 6x 640 nm red leds/ 6 x NW 5000K / 12 x WW 3000K..
All the leds driven @320mA..Power at plug for all three: ~72 W )
yield more ,in almost every case ,than one of GD SDS ( 12x 660nm Oslon 80 ,24x WW 2700K 95CRI Oslon 80 ,driven at 700mA ..Power at plug: ~75 Watt )
Considerably more ....Now how's that possible ?
For many reasons ..
Some regarding the led lights,others are related with other things,not the led lights themselves...
One good reason is the quality of light (spectrum ).A fine example that proves it's importance ,contrary to what is believed..
(Once more : Mj will grow under lots of odd/weird types of light -spectrums-...But not up to/close to her 'genetic potentional' ..
For a plant ,to reach that point ,many things have/must to be there and others better not to be there..(herbivorous insects for example or fungi ... )
Quality of light (spectrum) is a way crucial variable / parameter...
There's some crucial things that have to be cleared out ,
specially about the red leds and their effect-importance on mj ...
Later on ...
Another reason is the multiple small arrays ...
( - COBS are great ....But nothing will ever beat the 1-3 watters ,that are spreaded all over the leaf canopy.
Leds increase their growing efficiency( => better yields ) ,when used by numbers(unfortunately=>expensive way)...not as a single powerfull light source..
I want to build 5 "lights", 4 Flower only, 1 Flower/Veg. For the 4 small modules I thought I will take one 30W warmwhite array in middle and + about 10x 3W diodes on one heatsink and use a single driver -that cheapo 18pcs 650mA, -73V allpurpose driver. That would drive the 30W array with about 20W.
My Idea was to use for the 10x 3W diodes: 1cw, 4x 630nm, 4x 660nm and 1ww
After what ive learned here, should I leave the 660 (guess badies from satisled) and the CW out?
Yes ,if they are common eastern cheapos ...
Try for yourself..Built another simple panel with those reds ..Have it on veg and see what happens ...
Put it on flowering plants and see what will happen then ...
Try it ...
The CW can stay for vegging ...
For the 5th panel in the middle I planned to use 4x 100W Warmwhite arrays each @ 30W. 2x 30W red array @ 24 or so Watts.
Also I have 2x 30W CW arrays. You said those pretty much suck. Ok turn them off in flower. But for Veg should I use them instead of the WW? Or in Combination like 2x WW + 2x CW or 4WW and CW for veg. I also could run the CW in parallel for a bit better efficiency resulting in 15W each.
If you can switch them off during late flowring,there's no problem ,leave there ..
Vegging mj ,does not need only blue...
Yes she needs less light than when full flowering ,but still that light has to be rich in other wls too...
2x WW + 2x CW..looks good Have one-two red 620-630nm ,also ...
Sorry I can ask this else where if you want.
I dont want to spoil this thread of awesomeness
That spectrum is literally going off the deep end, must have been some stretched out plants.12x 660nm Oslon 80 ,24x WW 2700K 95CRI Oslon 80 ,driven at 700mA
Exactly!That spectrum is literally going off the deep end, must have been some stretched out plants.
Yes.....I'm afraid ...Satis only sells one type of 660nm so i guess it must be the crappy one. http://www.satisled.com/3w-high-power-red-led-star-emitter-for-plant-grow-light-660nm670nm_p433.html
Listen ...sry for editing my previous post.
This is what i added:
Does Astir use 3W @1W for better efficiency or directly 1W diodes?
The driver is like 6€ and if the leds cost another 5€, heatsink like 20€, what does make that 24W light cost 100€?
Is it the handmade part?
I wonder because:
Wattagewise Hans Panel is like about 3x Astir. Ok 72W vs 65W.
3x Astir costs0 285€, 1 Hans costs 180€. Regarding the W its about 4€/W vs 2,8€/W. Why?
So 285€ vs 180€ and hans only uses quality Cree and Osram vs Astir with good-cheapones
And Hans uses a better driver and a very nice reflector design and he drives those Leds fairly on low power too.
Where is the catch?
Astir seems to say they r non profit and id guess hans trys to make a (small) profit.
From what I know,they hand soldering the leds one-by one and they do not own a reflow oven ..regarding the 660 i guess i will trash them and buy more Red Arrays thanks a lot, not best coverage but so convenient
65$ BOM vs 85$. (custom,transport,profit,taxes ,etc included ) I think assembly could be most expensive, depending wether they use a reflow oven (i guess they do) but also if they have to drill threads and things like that.
Edit forget what i said, u should know best.
But great job developing them
I have a couple of dozen of those going and they are not so bad at all. There is an EpiLED chip inside. I did some crude caloric measurements of the radiometric efficiency and it's in the ballpark of 30%. They are slightly better than the 620nm from Satisled.Satis only sells one type of 660nm so i guess it must be the crappy one. http://www.satisled.com/3w-high-power-red-led-star-emitter-for-plant-grow-light-660nm670nm_p433.html