I just like to think of the value of the weed vs. the price of a bulb. Lets just assume that 10% less light = 10% less yield. Is 10% of your yield worth more than the bulb? So replacing bulbs often actually makes sense. That said, a CMH bulb costs more but lasts twice as long. So there is a little savings there but as you stated, it's more about the quality of the light. The UV thats in the CMH spectrum is awesome for resin production too. The HPS still has the far red but yields people have reported are either really good or really bad. That tells me that some people may be running the lights too close?? I do think a perfect room for me would have tall ceilings and use a mix of DE HPS and DE CMH with LED on the side lighting.