It's a type of soil even if the industry lingo leads you to believe otherwise.
It contains organic matter. Supplies nutrients to plants. And supports biological activity. It's soil by definition.
I prefer the term "growing media".....Not "really" a "soil." BUT, I get your point of contention...
The link you gave is
nice. It also points to my point on soil vs. a "media," as far as silica use goes...The author kinda glides by the soil vs. media point but, it is there.
As with any neutral media. It is considered a "hydro" style grow as far as feeding and pHing go. Now I'm sorta using your definition standards to apply this ideal...
You can't apply Mycorrhizal activity as a definition of being a"soil" either. Myco's simply need a media to attach to and grow. Soilless provides that.
"True" hydropnic grow styles,
do not....
A Zyme product can work without that media to attah to "need,"
as it attach's directly to the root system. This spectrum of myco's. Feeds off the "shed" cellulose from the roots.. They do not rely on carbs from any other source and self replicate by that....
Still, the use of many synthetic nutrients. Tend to stunt it's ability to reproduce. That's part of why some good lines have you feed a zyme product all run long....This is a good bet for straight hydro style's....Not so much for even soilless...Another point of profit for a nutrient maker to have you applying these products all grow long. In media grows.
A good example of a "zyme" spectrum product that does
not have you reapplying the product - GREAT WHITE root dip myco's.
I simply added more information to the thread progression....Not an argument or attack upon your point of view.....Like I said, Nice link!
Can just anything support plant life? Most consider it an amendment when you use it to condition native soils. In our container grows once compost, EWC, greensand etc is added you effectively turn it into a soil.
Kinda depends on the amounts and diversity of the things your amending with, to create that definition... I see your logic but, to me, soil is an organic, self supporting living biome...Depleted soil is still a soil, you just need to recharge it...But your right. The key is to amend a media with EWC. Compost, aeration component, mineral and a nutrient charge = soil is born...
There was for a while, a "foam" media that was completely inert......I found it a novel idea....Didn't try it and don't see it on the market (at least around here) anymore....